Why inconsistency is not hell: Making room for inconsistency in science

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

3 Scopus citations

Abstract

On most accounts of belief change, inconsistent belief systems are an “epistemic hell” to be avoided at all costs (see, e.g., Gärdenfors 1988, p. 51). From a normative point of view, we can perhaps understand why this is the case. The underlying logic of most theories of belief change is classical, and classical logic is explosive, that is, everything follows from a contradiction. And a belief system from which everything follows should definitely be avoided. It is certainly of not much use if one wants to determine what one should believe and what one should do. In a number of works, Issac Levi challenged this way of approaching the issue. On his view, there are contexts in which inconsistent belief systems are bound to happen. This is the case, for example, of observations. According to Levi, in some contexts it is legitimate to add a doxastic proposition to a belief system with which it is inconsistent: “Making observations and coming to fully believe propositions incompatible with one's initial convictions is a case in point” (Levi 1991, p. 68). The idea is that we may inadvertently tumble into inconsistency as the result of “deploying a reliable program for routine expansion” (ibid., p. 110), that is, as the result of adding a new belief to our belief system. In other words, descriptively at least, inconsistent belief systems simply happen, and this fact needs to be accommodated.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Title of host publicationKnowledge and Inquiry: Essays on the Pragmatism of Isaac Levi
PublisherCambridge University Press
Pages70-86
Number of pages17
ISBN (Print)9780511584312, 9780521845564
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2006
Externally publishedYes

    Fingerprint

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Arts and Humanities(all)

Cite this

Bueno, O. (2006). Why inconsistency is not hell: Making room for inconsistency in science. In Knowledge and Inquiry: Essays on the Pragmatism of Isaac Levi (pp. 70-86). Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511584312.007