What is the evidence for chronic pain being etiologically associated with the DSM-IV category of sleep disorder due to a general medical condition? A structured evidence-based review

David A Fishbain, Brandly Cole, John E Lewis, Jinrun Gao

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

30 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Design: This is a structured evidence-based review of all available studies on the relationship between chronic pain and sleep problems as defined by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) category of sleep disorder due to a general medical condition. Objectives.: To determine whether chronic pain is etiologically associated with this sleep category. Methods.: Computer and manual literature searches yielded 146 references that addressed this area of study. One hundred and five studies were excluded from detailed review based on exclusion criteria detailed by this category of sleep disorders. Forty-one studies were reviewed in detail and sorted according to six natural groupings: multivariate analysis, prospective studies, path analysis, correlation between pain and sleep problems, univariate analysis using comparison groups, and do nonsedating drugs with analgesic properties improve sleep? Study characteristics were abstracted into tabular form and each report was characterized by the type of study it represented according to the Agency for Health Care Policy and Research (AHCPR) guidelines. Each study was independently evaluated by two raters according to 12 quality criteria and an independent quality score was calculated. Studies were not utilized in the calculations unless their quality score (utilizing both raters) was greater than 60%. For each of the above groupings, an average quality score was calculated and a calculation performed as to the percentage of studies that supported the hypothesis that pain is etiologically related to the above DSM-IV category of sleep disorders. Finally, the strength and consistency of the evidence for this hypothesis was rated according to the AHCPR guidelines. Results.: Of the 41 reports, all had quality scores greater than 60%. In all the above groupings except for multivariate analysis, 100% of the studies supported this hypothesis. In the multivariate analysis grouping, 77.2% of the studies supported this hypothesis. The strength and consistency of this evidence was rated at A (highest possible) for all study groupings except multivariate (B rating) and path analysis where there were too few studies to generate a conclusion. For all the studies combined, 89.7% of the studies supported this hypothesis. This evidence was rated as A: consistent, multiple studies. Conclusions.: The results of this evidence-based structured review indicate that for the pain-sleep studies defined by the DSM-IV category of sleep disorder due to a general medical condition,chronic pain may be etiologically related to that sleep problem. However, these results do not preclude this relationship from being bidirectional.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)158-179
Number of pages22
JournalPain Medicine
Volume11
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 1 2010

Fingerprint

Chronic Pain
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders
Sleep
United States Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality
Multivariate Analysis
Pain
Guidelines
Analgesics
Sleep Wake Disorders
Prospective Studies

Keywords

  • Chronic nonmalignant pain
  • Chronic pain
  • Depression
  • Insomnia
  • Pain
  • Sleep
  • Sleep abnormalities
  • Sleep disorder

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Clinical Neurology
  • Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine

Cite this

What is the evidence for chronic pain being etiologically associated with the DSM-IV category of sleep disorder due to a general medical condition? A structured evidence-based review. / Fishbain, David A; Cole, Brandly; Lewis, John E; Gao, Jinrun.

In: Pain Medicine, Vol. 11, No. 2, 01.02.2010, p. 158-179.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{b53eeea5e1fc41bd8e6fd842c4789a63,
title = "What is the evidence for chronic pain being etiologically associated with the DSM-IV category of sleep disorder due to a general medical condition? A structured evidence-based review",
abstract = "Design: This is a structured evidence-based review of all available studies on the relationship between chronic pain and sleep problems as defined by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) category of sleep disorder due to a general medical condition. Objectives.: To determine whether chronic pain is etiologically associated with this sleep category. Methods.: Computer and manual literature searches yielded 146 references that addressed this area of study. One hundred and five studies were excluded from detailed review based on exclusion criteria detailed by this category of sleep disorders. Forty-one studies were reviewed in detail and sorted according to six natural groupings: multivariate analysis, prospective studies, path analysis, correlation between pain and sleep problems, univariate analysis using comparison groups, and do nonsedating drugs with analgesic properties improve sleep? Study characteristics were abstracted into tabular form and each report was characterized by the type of study it represented according to the Agency for Health Care Policy and Research (AHCPR) guidelines. Each study was independently evaluated by two raters according to 12 quality criteria and an independent quality score was calculated. Studies were not utilized in the calculations unless their quality score (utilizing both raters) was greater than 60{\%}. For each of the above groupings, an average quality score was calculated and a calculation performed as to the percentage of studies that supported the hypothesis that pain is etiologically related to the above DSM-IV category of sleep disorders. Finally, the strength and consistency of the evidence for this hypothesis was rated according to the AHCPR guidelines. Results.: Of the 41 reports, all had quality scores greater than 60{\%}. In all the above groupings except for multivariate analysis, 100{\%} of the studies supported this hypothesis. In the multivariate analysis grouping, 77.2{\%} of the studies supported this hypothesis. The strength and consistency of this evidence was rated at A (highest possible) for all study groupings except multivariate (B rating) and path analysis where there were too few studies to generate a conclusion. For all the studies combined, 89.7{\%} of the studies supported this hypothesis. This evidence was rated as A: consistent, multiple studies. Conclusions.: The results of this evidence-based structured review indicate that for the pain-sleep studies defined by the DSM-IV category of sleep disorder due to a general medical condition,chronic pain may be etiologically related to that sleep problem. However, these results do not preclude this relationship from being bidirectional.",
keywords = "Chronic nonmalignant pain, Chronic pain, Depression, Insomnia, Pain, Sleep, Sleep abnormalities, Sleep disorder",
author = "Fishbain, {David A} and Brandly Cole and Lewis, {John E} and Jinrun Gao",
year = "2010",
month = "2",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/j.1526-4637.2009.00706.x",
language = "English",
volume = "11",
pages = "158--179",
journal = "Pain Medicine",
issn = "1526-2375",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - What is the evidence for chronic pain being etiologically associated with the DSM-IV category of sleep disorder due to a general medical condition? A structured evidence-based review

AU - Fishbain, David A

AU - Cole, Brandly

AU - Lewis, John E

AU - Gao, Jinrun

PY - 2010/2/1

Y1 - 2010/2/1

N2 - Design: This is a structured evidence-based review of all available studies on the relationship between chronic pain and sleep problems as defined by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) category of sleep disorder due to a general medical condition. Objectives.: To determine whether chronic pain is etiologically associated with this sleep category. Methods.: Computer and manual literature searches yielded 146 references that addressed this area of study. One hundred and five studies were excluded from detailed review based on exclusion criteria detailed by this category of sleep disorders. Forty-one studies were reviewed in detail and sorted according to six natural groupings: multivariate analysis, prospective studies, path analysis, correlation between pain and sleep problems, univariate analysis using comparison groups, and do nonsedating drugs with analgesic properties improve sleep? Study characteristics were abstracted into tabular form and each report was characterized by the type of study it represented according to the Agency for Health Care Policy and Research (AHCPR) guidelines. Each study was independently evaluated by two raters according to 12 quality criteria and an independent quality score was calculated. Studies were not utilized in the calculations unless their quality score (utilizing both raters) was greater than 60%. For each of the above groupings, an average quality score was calculated and a calculation performed as to the percentage of studies that supported the hypothesis that pain is etiologically related to the above DSM-IV category of sleep disorders. Finally, the strength and consistency of the evidence for this hypothesis was rated according to the AHCPR guidelines. Results.: Of the 41 reports, all had quality scores greater than 60%. In all the above groupings except for multivariate analysis, 100% of the studies supported this hypothesis. In the multivariate analysis grouping, 77.2% of the studies supported this hypothesis. The strength and consistency of this evidence was rated at A (highest possible) for all study groupings except multivariate (B rating) and path analysis where there were too few studies to generate a conclusion. For all the studies combined, 89.7% of the studies supported this hypothesis. This evidence was rated as A: consistent, multiple studies. Conclusions.: The results of this evidence-based structured review indicate that for the pain-sleep studies defined by the DSM-IV category of sleep disorder due to a general medical condition,chronic pain may be etiologically related to that sleep problem. However, these results do not preclude this relationship from being bidirectional.

AB - Design: This is a structured evidence-based review of all available studies on the relationship between chronic pain and sleep problems as defined by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) category of sleep disorder due to a general medical condition. Objectives.: To determine whether chronic pain is etiologically associated with this sleep category. Methods.: Computer and manual literature searches yielded 146 references that addressed this area of study. One hundred and five studies were excluded from detailed review based on exclusion criteria detailed by this category of sleep disorders. Forty-one studies were reviewed in detail and sorted according to six natural groupings: multivariate analysis, prospective studies, path analysis, correlation between pain and sleep problems, univariate analysis using comparison groups, and do nonsedating drugs with analgesic properties improve sleep? Study characteristics were abstracted into tabular form and each report was characterized by the type of study it represented according to the Agency for Health Care Policy and Research (AHCPR) guidelines. Each study was independently evaluated by two raters according to 12 quality criteria and an independent quality score was calculated. Studies were not utilized in the calculations unless their quality score (utilizing both raters) was greater than 60%. For each of the above groupings, an average quality score was calculated and a calculation performed as to the percentage of studies that supported the hypothesis that pain is etiologically related to the above DSM-IV category of sleep disorders. Finally, the strength and consistency of the evidence for this hypothesis was rated according to the AHCPR guidelines. Results.: Of the 41 reports, all had quality scores greater than 60%. In all the above groupings except for multivariate analysis, 100% of the studies supported this hypothesis. In the multivariate analysis grouping, 77.2% of the studies supported this hypothesis. The strength and consistency of this evidence was rated at A (highest possible) for all study groupings except multivariate (B rating) and path analysis where there were too few studies to generate a conclusion. For all the studies combined, 89.7% of the studies supported this hypothesis. This evidence was rated as A: consistent, multiple studies. Conclusions.: The results of this evidence-based structured review indicate that for the pain-sleep studies defined by the DSM-IV category of sleep disorder due to a general medical condition,chronic pain may be etiologically related to that sleep problem. However, these results do not preclude this relationship from being bidirectional.

KW - Chronic nonmalignant pain

KW - Chronic pain

KW - Depression

KW - Insomnia

KW - Pain

KW - Sleep

KW - Sleep abnormalities

KW - Sleep disorder

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=75249105058&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=75249105058&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/j.1526-4637.2009.00706.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1526-4637.2009.00706.x

M3 - Article

C2 - 19788712

AN - SCOPUS:75249105058

VL - 11

SP - 158

EP - 179

JO - Pain Medicine

JF - Pain Medicine

SN - 1526-2375

IS - 2

ER -