Traditional and molecular analyses for fecal indicator bacteria in non-point source subtropical recreational marine waters

Christopher D. Sinigalliano, Jay M. Fleisher, Maribeth L. Gidley, Helena M Solo-Gabriele, Tomoyuki Shibata, Lisa R W Plano, Samir M. Elmir, David Wanless, Jakub Bartkowiak, Rene Boiteau, Kelly Withum, Amir M. Abdelzaher, Guoqing He, Cristina Ortega, Xiaofang Zhu, Mary E. Wright, Jonathan Kish, Julie Hollenbeck, Troy Scott, Lorraine C. Backer & 1 others Lora E. Fleming

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

76 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The use of enterococci as the primary fecal indicator bacteria (FIB) for the determination of recreational water safety has been questioned, particularly in sub/tropical marine waters without known point sources of sewage. Alternative FIB (such as the Bacteroidales group) and alternative measurement methods (such as rapid molecular testing) have been proposed to supplement or replace current marine water quality testing methods which require culturing enterococci. Moreover, environmental parameters have also been proposed to supplement current monitoring programs. The objective of this study was to evaluate the health risks to humans from exposure to subtropical recreational marine waters with no known point source. The study reported symptoms between one set of human subjects randomly assigned to marine water exposure with intensive environmental monitoring compared with other subjects who did not have exposure. In addition, illness outcomes among the exposed bathers were compared to levels of traditional and alternative FIB (as measured by culture-based and molecular-based methods), and compared to easily measured environmental parameters. Results demonstrated an increase in self-reported gastrointestinal, respiratory and skin illnesses among bathers vs. non-bathers. Among the bathers, a dose-response relationship by logistic regression modeling was observed for skin illness, where illness was positively related to enterococci enumeration by membrane filtration (odds ratio = 1.46 [95% confidence interval = 0.97-2.21] per increasing log10 unit of enterococci exposure) and positively related to 24 h antecedent rain fall (1.04 [1.01-1.07] per increasing millimeters of rain). Acute febrile respiratory illness was inversely related to water temperature (0.74 [0.56-0.98] per increasing degree of water temperature). There were no significant dose-response relationships between report of human illness and any of the other FIB or environmental measures. Therefore, for non-point source subtropical recreational marine waters, this study suggests that humans may be at increased risk of reported illness, and that the currently recommended and investigational FIB may not track gastrointestinal illness under these conditions; the relationship between other human illness and environmental measures is less clear.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)3763-3772
Number of pages10
JournalWater Research
Volume44
Issue number13
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 1 2010

Fingerprint

Bacteria
bacterium
dose-response relationship
Water
point source
skin
water temperature
water
Rain
Skin
testing method
measurement method
environmental monitoring
Ocean currents
health risk
confidence interval
logistics
Monitoring
Health risks
sewage

Keywords

  • Bacteroidales
  • Chromogenic substrate
  • Enterococci
  • Gastrointestinal illness
  • Indicator organisms
  • Membrane filtration plate counts
  • Quantitative PCR
  • Recreational water quality
  • Respiratory illness
  • Skin illness

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Water Science and Technology
  • Waste Management and Disposal
  • Pollution
  • Ecological Modeling

Cite this

Traditional and molecular analyses for fecal indicator bacteria in non-point source subtropical recreational marine waters. / Sinigalliano, Christopher D.; Fleisher, Jay M.; Gidley, Maribeth L.; Solo-Gabriele, Helena M; Shibata, Tomoyuki; Plano, Lisa R W; Elmir, Samir M.; Wanless, David; Bartkowiak, Jakub; Boiteau, Rene; Withum, Kelly; Abdelzaher, Amir M.; He, Guoqing; Ortega, Cristina; Zhu, Xiaofang; Wright, Mary E.; Kish, Jonathan; Hollenbeck, Julie; Scott, Troy; Backer, Lorraine C.; Fleming, Lora E.

In: Water Research, Vol. 44, No. 13, 01.07.2010, p. 3763-3772.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Sinigalliano, CD, Fleisher, JM, Gidley, ML, Solo-Gabriele, HM, Shibata, T, Plano, LRW, Elmir, SM, Wanless, D, Bartkowiak, J, Boiteau, R, Withum, K, Abdelzaher, AM, He, G, Ortega, C, Zhu, X, Wright, ME, Kish, J, Hollenbeck, J, Scott, T, Backer, LC & Fleming, LE 2010, 'Traditional and molecular analyses for fecal indicator bacteria in non-point source subtropical recreational marine waters', Water Research, vol. 44, no. 13, pp. 3763-3772. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2010.04.026
Sinigalliano, Christopher D. ; Fleisher, Jay M. ; Gidley, Maribeth L. ; Solo-Gabriele, Helena M ; Shibata, Tomoyuki ; Plano, Lisa R W ; Elmir, Samir M. ; Wanless, David ; Bartkowiak, Jakub ; Boiteau, Rene ; Withum, Kelly ; Abdelzaher, Amir M. ; He, Guoqing ; Ortega, Cristina ; Zhu, Xiaofang ; Wright, Mary E. ; Kish, Jonathan ; Hollenbeck, Julie ; Scott, Troy ; Backer, Lorraine C. ; Fleming, Lora E. / Traditional and molecular analyses for fecal indicator bacteria in non-point source subtropical recreational marine waters. In: Water Research. 2010 ; Vol. 44, No. 13. pp. 3763-3772.
@article{95263b7e86234ea9b6f2d8201e801ac0,
title = "Traditional and molecular analyses for fecal indicator bacteria in non-point source subtropical recreational marine waters",
abstract = "The use of enterococci as the primary fecal indicator bacteria (FIB) for the determination of recreational water safety has been questioned, particularly in sub/tropical marine waters without known point sources of sewage. Alternative FIB (such as the Bacteroidales group) and alternative measurement methods (such as rapid molecular testing) have been proposed to supplement or replace current marine water quality testing methods which require culturing enterococci. Moreover, environmental parameters have also been proposed to supplement current monitoring programs. The objective of this study was to evaluate the health risks to humans from exposure to subtropical recreational marine waters with no known point source. The study reported symptoms between one set of human subjects randomly assigned to marine water exposure with intensive environmental monitoring compared with other subjects who did not have exposure. In addition, illness outcomes among the exposed bathers were compared to levels of traditional and alternative FIB (as measured by culture-based and molecular-based methods), and compared to easily measured environmental parameters. Results demonstrated an increase in self-reported gastrointestinal, respiratory and skin illnesses among bathers vs. non-bathers. Among the bathers, a dose-response relationship by logistic regression modeling was observed for skin illness, where illness was positively related to enterococci enumeration by membrane filtration (odds ratio = 1.46 [95{\%} confidence interval = 0.97-2.21] per increasing log10 unit of enterococci exposure) and positively related to 24 h antecedent rain fall (1.04 [1.01-1.07] per increasing millimeters of rain). Acute febrile respiratory illness was inversely related to water temperature (0.74 [0.56-0.98] per increasing degree of water temperature). There were no significant dose-response relationships between report of human illness and any of the other FIB or environmental measures. Therefore, for non-point source subtropical recreational marine waters, this study suggests that humans may be at increased risk of reported illness, and that the currently recommended and investigational FIB may not track gastrointestinal illness under these conditions; the relationship between other human illness and environmental measures is less clear.",
keywords = "Bacteroidales, Chromogenic substrate, Enterococci, Gastrointestinal illness, Indicator organisms, Membrane filtration plate counts, Quantitative PCR, Recreational water quality, Respiratory illness, Skin illness",
author = "Sinigalliano, {Christopher D.} and Fleisher, {Jay M.} and Gidley, {Maribeth L.} and Solo-Gabriele, {Helena M} and Tomoyuki Shibata and Plano, {Lisa R W} and Elmir, {Samir M.} and David Wanless and Jakub Bartkowiak and Rene Boiteau and Kelly Withum and Abdelzaher, {Amir M.} and Guoqing He and Cristina Ortega and Xiaofang Zhu and Wright, {Mary E.} and Jonathan Kish and Julie Hollenbeck and Troy Scott and Backer, {Lorraine C.} and Fleming, {Lora E.}",
year = "2010",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.watres.2010.04.026",
language = "English",
volume = "44",
pages = "3763--3772",
journal = "Water Research",
issn = "0043-1354",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",
number = "13",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Traditional and molecular analyses for fecal indicator bacteria in non-point source subtropical recreational marine waters

AU - Sinigalliano, Christopher D.

AU - Fleisher, Jay M.

AU - Gidley, Maribeth L.

AU - Solo-Gabriele, Helena M

AU - Shibata, Tomoyuki

AU - Plano, Lisa R W

AU - Elmir, Samir M.

AU - Wanless, David

AU - Bartkowiak, Jakub

AU - Boiteau, Rene

AU - Withum, Kelly

AU - Abdelzaher, Amir M.

AU - He, Guoqing

AU - Ortega, Cristina

AU - Zhu, Xiaofang

AU - Wright, Mary E.

AU - Kish, Jonathan

AU - Hollenbeck, Julie

AU - Scott, Troy

AU - Backer, Lorraine C.

AU - Fleming, Lora E.

PY - 2010/7/1

Y1 - 2010/7/1

N2 - The use of enterococci as the primary fecal indicator bacteria (FIB) for the determination of recreational water safety has been questioned, particularly in sub/tropical marine waters without known point sources of sewage. Alternative FIB (such as the Bacteroidales group) and alternative measurement methods (such as rapid molecular testing) have been proposed to supplement or replace current marine water quality testing methods which require culturing enterococci. Moreover, environmental parameters have also been proposed to supplement current monitoring programs. The objective of this study was to evaluate the health risks to humans from exposure to subtropical recreational marine waters with no known point source. The study reported symptoms between one set of human subjects randomly assigned to marine water exposure with intensive environmental monitoring compared with other subjects who did not have exposure. In addition, illness outcomes among the exposed bathers were compared to levels of traditional and alternative FIB (as measured by culture-based and molecular-based methods), and compared to easily measured environmental parameters. Results demonstrated an increase in self-reported gastrointestinal, respiratory and skin illnesses among bathers vs. non-bathers. Among the bathers, a dose-response relationship by logistic regression modeling was observed for skin illness, where illness was positively related to enterococci enumeration by membrane filtration (odds ratio = 1.46 [95% confidence interval = 0.97-2.21] per increasing log10 unit of enterococci exposure) and positively related to 24 h antecedent rain fall (1.04 [1.01-1.07] per increasing millimeters of rain). Acute febrile respiratory illness was inversely related to water temperature (0.74 [0.56-0.98] per increasing degree of water temperature). There were no significant dose-response relationships between report of human illness and any of the other FIB or environmental measures. Therefore, for non-point source subtropical recreational marine waters, this study suggests that humans may be at increased risk of reported illness, and that the currently recommended and investigational FIB may not track gastrointestinal illness under these conditions; the relationship between other human illness and environmental measures is less clear.

AB - The use of enterococci as the primary fecal indicator bacteria (FIB) for the determination of recreational water safety has been questioned, particularly in sub/tropical marine waters without known point sources of sewage. Alternative FIB (such as the Bacteroidales group) and alternative measurement methods (such as rapid molecular testing) have been proposed to supplement or replace current marine water quality testing methods which require culturing enterococci. Moreover, environmental parameters have also been proposed to supplement current monitoring programs. The objective of this study was to evaluate the health risks to humans from exposure to subtropical recreational marine waters with no known point source. The study reported symptoms between one set of human subjects randomly assigned to marine water exposure with intensive environmental monitoring compared with other subjects who did not have exposure. In addition, illness outcomes among the exposed bathers were compared to levels of traditional and alternative FIB (as measured by culture-based and molecular-based methods), and compared to easily measured environmental parameters. Results demonstrated an increase in self-reported gastrointestinal, respiratory and skin illnesses among bathers vs. non-bathers. Among the bathers, a dose-response relationship by logistic regression modeling was observed for skin illness, where illness was positively related to enterococci enumeration by membrane filtration (odds ratio = 1.46 [95% confidence interval = 0.97-2.21] per increasing log10 unit of enterococci exposure) and positively related to 24 h antecedent rain fall (1.04 [1.01-1.07] per increasing millimeters of rain). Acute febrile respiratory illness was inversely related to water temperature (0.74 [0.56-0.98] per increasing degree of water temperature). There were no significant dose-response relationships between report of human illness and any of the other FIB or environmental measures. Therefore, for non-point source subtropical recreational marine waters, this study suggests that humans may be at increased risk of reported illness, and that the currently recommended and investigational FIB may not track gastrointestinal illness under these conditions; the relationship between other human illness and environmental measures is less clear.

KW - Bacteroidales

KW - Chromogenic substrate

KW - Enterococci

KW - Gastrointestinal illness

KW - Indicator organisms

KW - Membrane filtration plate counts

KW - Quantitative PCR

KW - Recreational water quality

KW - Respiratory illness

KW - Skin illness

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=77953811721&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=77953811721&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.watres.2010.04.026

DO - 10.1016/j.watres.2010.04.026

M3 - Article

VL - 44

SP - 3763

EP - 3772

JO - Water Research

JF - Water Research

SN - 0043-1354

IS - 13

ER -