Seeking an expanded suite of management tools

Implications of rapidly-evolving adaptive response mechanisms (e.g., "School-mix feedback")

Andrew Bakun

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

13 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The premise is presented that durable adaptive responses may be developed within fish populations on much more rapid time scales (e.g., 5-50 yrs) than possible via classical genetics-based Darwinian evolution. If so, there are major implications for the way we may view fish population dynamics. For example, any degree of understanding of the adaptive mechanisms involved, or even a well-founded belief that such mechanisms are operating, would open up a broad range of new considerations for adaptive management responses, design of mitigation actions, and foresight as to the nature and course of climatic or anthropogenic impacts. There is even reason to think that such rapidly-evolving response processes operating within exploited resource populations could cause some conventional fishery management responses to be absolutely wrong (e.g., serving to trap and maintain the populations within low-productivity phases). Moreover, unless the mechanisms involved are understood, it may be very difficult to ever sort out, understand, and adequately allow for the interacting effects of low frequency climate variability. In order to have a concrete basis for illustrating and exploring these issues, the operation of one potential mechanism of this type, the "school-mix feedback" mechanism, is outlined through the use of simple diagrammatic cartoons. These are intended to quickly impart a general degree of understanding of the operation of this particular mechanism and the likelihood that it must operate at least to some degree in real ocean systems. More generally, they may serve to illustrate the natural function of mechanisms of this type in preserving the populations that may employ them, and of the manner in which their operation might affect: (1) the efficacy of fishery management actions, and (2) the interpretation of empirical climate-fisheries relationships and their potential utility as bases for forecasts and management responses. Possibilities for innovative adaptive management actions are suggested.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)463-483
Number of pages21
JournalBulletin of Marine Science
Volume76
Issue number2
StatePublished - Mar 1 2005

Fingerprint

adaptive management
fishery management
feedback mechanism
climate
fish
fisheries management
population dynamics
mitigation
fishery
timescale
productivity
ocean
resource
anthropogenic activities
traps
oceans
fisheries
school
forecast
effect

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Aquatic Science
  • Oceanography

Cite this

Seeking an expanded suite of management tools : Implications of rapidly-evolving adaptive response mechanisms (e.g., "School-mix feedback"). / Bakun, Andrew.

In: Bulletin of Marine Science, Vol. 76, No. 2, 01.03.2005, p. 463-483.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{217914c57c8a4fb186425392f54ed341,
title = "Seeking an expanded suite of management tools: Implications of rapidly-evolving adaptive response mechanisms (e.g., {"}School-mix feedback{"})",
abstract = "The premise is presented that durable adaptive responses may be developed within fish populations on much more rapid time scales (e.g., 5-50 yrs) than possible via classical genetics-based Darwinian evolution. If so, there are major implications for the way we may view fish population dynamics. For example, any degree of understanding of the adaptive mechanisms involved, or even a well-founded belief that such mechanisms are operating, would open up a broad range of new considerations for adaptive management responses, design of mitigation actions, and foresight as to the nature and course of climatic or anthropogenic impacts. There is even reason to think that such rapidly-evolving response processes operating within exploited resource populations could cause some conventional fishery management responses to be absolutely wrong (e.g., serving to trap and maintain the populations within low-productivity phases). Moreover, unless the mechanisms involved are understood, it may be very difficult to ever sort out, understand, and adequately allow for the interacting effects of low frequency climate variability. In order to have a concrete basis for illustrating and exploring these issues, the operation of one potential mechanism of this type, the {"}school-mix feedback{"} mechanism, is outlined through the use of simple diagrammatic cartoons. These are intended to quickly impart a general degree of understanding of the operation of this particular mechanism and the likelihood that it must operate at least to some degree in real ocean systems. More generally, they may serve to illustrate the natural function of mechanisms of this type in preserving the populations that may employ them, and of the manner in which their operation might affect: (1) the efficacy of fishery management actions, and (2) the interpretation of empirical climate-fisheries relationships and their potential utility as bases for forecasts and management responses. Possibilities for innovative adaptive management actions are suggested.",
author = "Andrew Bakun",
year = "2005",
month = "3",
day = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "76",
pages = "463--483",
journal = "Bulletin of Marine Science",
issn = "0007-4977",
publisher = "Rosenstiel School of Marine and Atmospheric Science",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Seeking an expanded suite of management tools

T2 - Implications of rapidly-evolving adaptive response mechanisms (e.g., "School-mix feedback")

AU - Bakun, Andrew

PY - 2005/3/1

Y1 - 2005/3/1

N2 - The premise is presented that durable adaptive responses may be developed within fish populations on much more rapid time scales (e.g., 5-50 yrs) than possible via classical genetics-based Darwinian evolution. If so, there are major implications for the way we may view fish population dynamics. For example, any degree of understanding of the adaptive mechanisms involved, or even a well-founded belief that such mechanisms are operating, would open up a broad range of new considerations for adaptive management responses, design of mitigation actions, and foresight as to the nature and course of climatic or anthropogenic impacts. There is even reason to think that such rapidly-evolving response processes operating within exploited resource populations could cause some conventional fishery management responses to be absolutely wrong (e.g., serving to trap and maintain the populations within low-productivity phases). Moreover, unless the mechanisms involved are understood, it may be very difficult to ever sort out, understand, and adequately allow for the interacting effects of low frequency climate variability. In order to have a concrete basis for illustrating and exploring these issues, the operation of one potential mechanism of this type, the "school-mix feedback" mechanism, is outlined through the use of simple diagrammatic cartoons. These are intended to quickly impart a general degree of understanding of the operation of this particular mechanism and the likelihood that it must operate at least to some degree in real ocean systems. More generally, they may serve to illustrate the natural function of mechanisms of this type in preserving the populations that may employ them, and of the manner in which their operation might affect: (1) the efficacy of fishery management actions, and (2) the interpretation of empirical climate-fisheries relationships and their potential utility as bases for forecasts and management responses. Possibilities for innovative adaptive management actions are suggested.

AB - The premise is presented that durable adaptive responses may be developed within fish populations on much more rapid time scales (e.g., 5-50 yrs) than possible via classical genetics-based Darwinian evolution. If so, there are major implications for the way we may view fish population dynamics. For example, any degree of understanding of the adaptive mechanisms involved, or even a well-founded belief that such mechanisms are operating, would open up a broad range of new considerations for adaptive management responses, design of mitigation actions, and foresight as to the nature and course of climatic or anthropogenic impacts. There is even reason to think that such rapidly-evolving response processes operating within exploited resource populations could cause some conventional fishery management responses to be absolutely wrong (e.g., serving to trap and maintain the populations within low-productivity phases). Moreover, unless the mechanisms involved are understood, it may be very difficult to ever sort out, understand, and adequately allow for the interacting effects of low frequency climate variability. In order to have a concrete basis for illustrating and exploring these issues, the operation of one potential mechanism of this type, the "school-mix feedback" mechanism, is outlined through the use of simple diagrammatic cartoons. These are intended to quickly impart a general degree of understanding of the operation of this particular mechanism and the likelihood that it must operate at least to some degree in real ocean systems. More generally, they may serve to illustrate the natural function of mechanisms of this type in preserving the populations that may employ them, and of the manner in which their operation might affect: (1) the efficacy of fishery management actions, and (2) the interpretation of empirical climate-fisheries relationships and their potential utility as bases for forecasts and management responses. Possibilities for innovative adaptive management actions are suggested.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=17444391740&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=17444391740&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 76

SP - 463

EP - 483

JO - Bulletin of Marine Science

JF - Bulletin of Marine Science

SN - 0007-4977

IS - 2

ER -