Saucers of mud: Why sympathy and altruism require empathy

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Empathy and helping motives are more closely connected than philosophers and psychologists have realized. Empathy doesn't just cause sympathetic concern for others, but is conceptually tied to it. When we empathize with someone's distress at their pain, we ourselves are distressed by that pain and that in itself necessarily constitutes a motive to rid them of that pain. But helping motives like compassion or concern for others can be shown to be conceptually impossible in the absence of empathy. Compassion as a feeling and compassion as a motive are thus inseparable from one another, and this then lets the Chinese complementarity of yin and yang enter the picture. Yin can be viewed as a kind of receptivity, and compassion as a feeling instantiates such receptivity; but compassion as a motive instantiates yang conceived along somewhat traditional lines as a form of strong purposiveness. If moral sentimentalism is on the right track, then the motives and feelings it views as foundational to normative morality turn out to instantiate yin and yang conceived in traditional terms as an indissoluble complementarity. Moral sentimentalism properly pursued allows East to meet West in the field of ethics and possibly in other areas of philosophy as well.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)12-26
Number of pages15
JournalEtica e Politica
Volume17
Issue number2
StatePublished - 2015

Fingerprint

altruism
sympathy
empathy
pain
psychologist
morality
Sympathy
Empathy
Altruism
moral philosophy
Compassion
cause
Pain

Keywords

  • Compassion
  • Complementarity
  • Empathy
  • Moral sentimentalism
  • Receptivity
  • Strength
  • Sympathy
  • Yin and Yang

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Philosophy
  • Sociology and Political Science

Cite this

Saucers of mud : Why sympathy and altruism require empathy. / Slote, Michael.

In: Etica e Politica, Vol. 17, No. 2, 2015, p. 12-26.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{9f0d332c4d8649f88b8600cc74d12473,
title = "Saucers of mud: Why sympathy and altruism require empathy",
abstract = "Empathy and helping motives are more closely connected than philosophers and psychologists have realized. Empathy doesn't just cause sympathetic concern for others, but is conceptually tied to it. When we empathize with someone's distress at their pain, we ourselves are distressed by that pain and that in itself necessarily constitutes a motive to rid them of that pain. But helping motives like compassion or concern for others can be shown to be conceptually impossible in the absence of empathy. Compassion as a feeling and compassion as a motive are thus inseparable from one another, and this then lets the Chinese complementarity of yin and yang enter the picture. Yin can be viewed as a kind of receptivity, and compassion as a feeling instantiates such receptivity; but compassion as a motive instantiates yang conceived along somewhat traditional lines as a form of strong purposiveness. If moral sentimentalism is on the right track, then the motives and feelings it views as foundational to normative morality turn out to instantiate yin and yang conceived in traditional terms as an indissoluble complementarity. Moral sentimentalism properly pursued allows East to meet West in the field of ethics and possibly in other areas of philosophy as well.",
keywords = "Compassion, Complementarity, Empathy, Moral sentimentalism, Receptivity, Strength, Sympathy, Yin and Yang",
author = "Michael Slote",
year = "2015",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "17",
pages = "12--26",
journal = "Etica e Politica",
issn = "1825-5167",
publisher = "University of Trieste, Department of Philosophy",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Saucers of mud

T2 - Why sympathy and altruism require empathy

AU - Slote, Michael

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - Empathy and helping motives are more closely connected than philosophers and psychologists have realized. Empathy doesn't just cause sympathetic concern for others, but is conceptually tied to it. When we empathize with someone's distress at their pain, we ourselves are distressed by that pain and that in itself necessarily constitutes a motive to rid them of that pain. But helping motives like compassion or concern for others can be shown to be conceptually impossible in the absence of empathy. Compassion as a feeling and compassion as a motive are thus inseparable from one another, and this then lets the Chinese complementarity of yin and yang enter the picture. Yin can be viewed as a kind of receptivity, and compassion as a feeling instantiates such receptivity; but compassion as a motive instantiates yang conceived along somewhat traditional lines as a form of strong purposiveness. If moral sentimentalism is on the right track, then the motives and feelings it views as foundational to normative morality turn out to instantiate yin and yang conceived in traditional terms as an indissoluble complementarity. Moral sentimentalism properly pursued allows East to meet West in the field of ethics and possibly in other areas of philosophy as well.

AB - Empathy and helping motives are more closely connected than philosophers and psychologists have realized. Empathy doesn't just cause sympathetic concern for others, but is conceptually tied to it. When we empathize with someone's distress at their pain, we ourselves are distressed by that pain and that in itself necessarily constitutes a motive to rid them of that pain. But helping motives like compassion or concern for others can be shown to be conceptually impossible in the absence of empathy. Compassion as a feeling and compassion as a motive are thus inseparable from one another, and this then lets the Chinese complementarity of yin and yang enter the picture. Yin can be viewed as a kind of receptivity, and compassion as a feeling instantiates such receptivity; but compassion as a motive instantiates yang conceived along somewhat traditional lines as a form of strong purposiveness. If moral sentimentalism is on the right track, then the motives and feelings it views as foundational to normative morality turn out to instantiate yin and yang conceived in traditional terms as an indissoluble complementarity. Moral sentimentalism properly pursued allows East to meet West in the field of ethics and possibly in other areas of philosophy as well.

KW - Compassion

KW - Complementarity

KW - Empathy

KW - Moral sentimentalism

KW - Receptivity

KW - Strength

KW - Sympathy

KW - Yin and Yang

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84971334403&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84971334403&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84971334403

VL - 17

SP - 12

EP - 26

JO - Etica e Politica

JF - Etica e Politica

SN - 1825-5167

IS - 2

ER -