Replacement of fish meal by a novel non-GM variety of soybean meal in cobia, Rachycentron canadum: Ingredient nutrient digestibility and growth performance

Jorge A. Suarez, Carlos Tudela, Drew Davis, Zachary Daugherty, Matthew Taynor, Lindsay Glass, Ronald Hoenig, Alejandro Buentello, Daniel D Benetti

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

12 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

A constraint for the expansion of cobia aquaculture is the availability of high quality formulated diets which reduce or eliminate fish meal (FM) protein. Therefore, the nutritive value of a novel soybean cultivar, Navita™ (Navita, non-genetically modified and selectively bred soy), and regular, commodity soybean meal (SBM, de-hulled, defatted, roasted and solvent-extracted) was evaluated for cobia, Rachycentron canadum via separate digestibility and growth trials. In the first experiment Navita's apparent digestibility coefficients (ADC) were higher than those of SBM for nearly every nutrient evaluated. Crude protein ADCs were 82 and 69% for Navita and SBM, respectively. Apparent DC for amino acids ranged from 68 to 109% for Navita whereas, amino acid ADCs for SBM varied from 42 to 98%. The feeding trial utilized fish of a size that more closely resembles commercial cobia stocking (1.8. kg), and was conducted over a 91-day period. Experimental diets (iso-nitrogenous and iso-energetic) were formulated such that 67% of the FM protein in the reference diet was replaced by either a combination of SBM. +. soy protein concentrate (SPC, Solae Profine®) labeled MXSB-diet, or by a combination of SPC. +. Navita; Navita-diet, hereafter. A fourth experimental diet had 80% of the FM protein replaced by a combination of Navita. +. SPC and was identified as Navita-high. No significant differences (P>. 0.05) were observed in fish fed the experimental diets for feed conversion ratio, protein efficiency ratio, feed efficiency, mean daily intake, gross protein intake, gross energy intake, visceral somatic index, muscle ratio, and hepatosomatic index. Fish fed the Navita-high diet had the lowest fish in:fish out ratio (FIFO) at 0.9. ±. 0.16. These results indicate that Navita meal can be incorporated at very high levels in the diet of marine carnivorous fish such as cobia with no detriment to performance, making it a prime candidate for FM replacement in aquafeeds.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)328-333
Number of pages6
JournalAquaculture
Volume416-417
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 5 2013

Fingerprint

Rachycentron canadum
digestibility
fish meal
soybean meal
soybean
growth performance
ingredients
replacement
diet
nutrient
experimental diets
nutrients
fish
protein
fish feeds
feed conversion
aquaculture feeds
soy protein concentrate
amino acids
hepatosomatic index

Keywords

  • Aquafeeds
  • Cobia
  • Digestibility
  • Fish meal replacement
  • Non-GM soy

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Aquatic Science

Cite this

Replacement of fish meal by a novel non-GM variety of soybean meal in cobia, Rachycentron canadum : Ingredient nutrient digestibility and growth performance. / Suarez, Jorge A.; Tudela, Carlos; Davis, Drew; Daugherty, Zachary; Taynor, Matthew; Glass, Lindsay; Hoenig, Ronald; Buentello, Alejandro; Benetti, Daniel D.

In: Aquaculture, Vol. 416-417, 05.12.2013, p. 328-333.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Suarez, Jorge A. ; Tudela, Carlos ; Davis, Drew ; Daugherty, Zachary ; Taynor, Matthew ; Glass, Lindsay ; Hoenig, Ronald ; Buentello, Alejandro ; Benetti, Daniel D. / Replacement of fish meal by a novel non-GM variety of soybean meal in cobia, Rachycentron canadum : Ingredient nutrient digestibility and growth performance. In: Aquaculture. 2013 ; Vol. 416-417. pp. 328-333.
@article{bb000755e501405ab5ec7ec4fa5345ae,
title = "Replacement of fish meal by a novel non-GM variety of soybean meal in cobia, Rachycentron canadum: Ingredient nutrient digestibility and growth performance",
abstract = "A constraint for the expansion of cobia aquaculture is the availability of high quality formulated diets which reduce or eliminate fish meal (FM) protein. Therefore, the nutritive value of a novel soybean cultivar, Navita™ (Navita, non-genetically modified and selectively bred soy), and regular, commodity soybean meal (SBM, de-hulled, defatted, roasted and solvent-extracted) was evaluated for cobia, Rachycentron canadum via separate digestibility and growth trials. In the first experiment Navita's apparent digestibility coefficients (ADC) were higher than those of SBM for nearly every nutrient evaluated. Crude protein ADCs were 82 and 69{\%} for Navita and SBM, respectively. Apparent DC for amino acids ranged from 68 to 109{\%} for Navita whereas, amino acid ADCs for SBM varied from 42 to 98{\%}. The feeding trial utilized fish of a size that more closely resembles commercial cobia stocking (1.8. kg), and was conducted over a 91-day period. Experimental diets (iso-nitrogenous and iso-energetic) were formulated such that 67{\%} of the FM protein in the reference diet was replaced by either a combination of SBM. +. soy protein concentrate (SPC, Solae Profine{\circledR}) labeled MXSB-diet, or by a combination of SPC. +. Navita; Navita-diet, hereafter. A fourth experimental diet had 80{\%} of the FM protein replaced by a combination of Navita. +. SPC and was identified as Navita-high. No significant differences (P>. 0.05) were observed in fish fed the experimental diets for feed conversion ratio, protein efficiency ratio, feed efficiency, mean daily intake, gross protein intake, gross energy intake, visceral somatic index, muscle ratio, and hepatosomatic index. Fish fed the Navita-high diet had the lowest fish in:fish out ratio (FIFO) at 0.9. ±. 0.16. These results indicate that Navita meal can be incorporated at very high levels in the diet of marine carnivorous fish such as cobia with no detriment to performance, making it a prime candidate for FM replacement in aquafeeds.",
keywords = "Aquafeeds, Cobia, Digestibility, Fish meal replacement, Non-GM soy",
author = "Suarez, {Jorge A.} and Carlos Tudela and Drew Davis and Zachary Daugherty and Matthew Taynor and Lindsay Glass and Ronald Hoenig and Alejandro Buentello and Benetti, {Daniel D}",
year = "2013",
month = "12",
day = "5",
doi = "10.1016/j.aquaculture.2013.09.049",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "416-417",
pages = "328--333",
journal = "Aquaculture",
issn = "0044-8486",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Replacement of fish meal by a novel non-GM variety of soybean meal in cobia, Rachycentron canadum

T2 - Ingredient nutrient digestibility and growth performance

AU - Suarez, Jorge A.

AU - Tudela, Carlos

AU - Davis, Drew

AU - Daugherty, Zachary

AU - Taynor, Matthew

AU - Glass, Lindsay

AU - Hoenig, Ronald

AU - Buentello, Alejandro

AU - Benetti, Daniel D

PY - 2013/12/5

Y1 - 2013/12/5

N2 - A constraint for the expansion of cobia aquaculture is the availability of high quality formulated diets which reduce or eliminate fish meal (FM) protein. Therefore, the nutritive value of a novel soybean cultivar, Navita™ (Navita, non-genetically modified and selectively bred soy), and regular, commodity soybean meal (SBM, de-hulled, defatted, roasted and solvent-extracted) was evaluated for cobia, Rachycentron canadum via separate digestibility and growth trials. In the first experiment Navita's apparent digestibility coefficients (ADC) were higher than those of SBM for nearly every nutrient evaluated. Crude protein ADCs were 82 and 69% for Navita and SBM, respectively. Apparent DC for amino acids ranged from 68 to 109% for Navita whereas, amino acid ADCs for SBM varied from 42 to 98%. The feeding trial utilized fish of a size that more closely resembles commercial cobia stocking (1.8. kg), and was conducted over a 91-day period. Experimental diets (iso-nitrogenous and iso-energetic) were formulated such that 67% of the FM protein in the reference diet was replaced by either a combination of SBM. +. soy protein concentrate (SPC, Solae Profine®) labeled MXSB-diet, or by a combination of SPC. +. Navita; Navita-diet, hereafter. A fourth experimental diet had 80% of the FM protein replaced by a combination of Navita. +. SPC and was identified as Navita-high. No significant differences (P>. 0.05) were observed in fish fed the experimental diets for feed conversion ratio, protein efficiency ratio, feed efficiency, mean daily intake, gross protein intake, gross energy intake, visceral somatic index, muscle ratio, and hepatosomatic index. Fish fed the Navita-high diet had the lowest fish in:fish out ratio (FIFO) at 0.9. ±. 0.16. These results indicate that Navita meal can be incorporated at very high levels in the diet of marine carnivorous fish such as cobia with no detriment to performance, making it a prime candidate for FM replacement in aquafeeds.

AB - A constraint for the expansion of cobia aquaculture is the availability of high quality formulated diets which reduce or eliminate fish meal (FM) protein. Therefore, the nutritive value of a novel soybean cultivar, Navita™ (Navita, non-genetically modified and selectively bred soy), and regular, commodity soybean meal (SBM, de-hulled, defatted, roasted and solvent-extracted) was evaluated for cobia, Rachycentron canadum via separate digestibility and growth trials. In the first experiment Navita's apparent digestibility coefficients (ADC) were higher than those of SBM for nearly every nutrient evaluated. Crude protein ADCs were 82 and 69% for Navita and SBM, respectively. Apparent DC for amino acids ranged from 68 to 109% for Navita whereas, amino acid ADCs for SBM varied from 42 to 98%. The feeding trial utilized fish of a size that more closely resembles commercial cobia stocking (1.8. kg), and was conducted over a 91-day period. Experimental diets (iso-nitrogenous and iso-energetic) were formulated such that 67% of the FM protein in the reference diet was replaced by either a combination of SBM. +. soy protein concentrate (SPC, Solae Profine®) labeled MXSB-diet, or by a combination of SPC. +. Navita; Navita-diet, hereafter. A fourth experimental diet had 80% of the FM protein replaced by a combination of Navita. +. SPC and was identified as Navita-high. No significant differences (P>. 0.05) were observed in fish fed the experimental diets for feed conversion ratio, protein efficiency ratio, feed efficiency, mean daily intake, gross protein intake, gross energy intake, visceral somatic index, muscle ratio, and hepatosomatic index. Fish fed the Navita-high diet had the lowest fish in:fish out ratio (FIFO) at 0.9. ±. 0.16. These results indicate that Navita meal can be incorporated at very high levels in the diet of marine carnivorous fish such as cobia with no detriment to performance, making it a prime candidate for FM replacement in aquafeeds.

KW - Aquafeeds

KW - Cobia

KW - Digestibility

KW - Fish meal replacement

KW - Non-GM soy

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84885350824&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84885350824&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.aquaculture.2013.09.049

DO - 10.1016/j.aquaculture.2013.09.049

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84885350824

VL - 416-417

SP - 328

EP - 333

JO - Aquaculture

JF - Aquaculture

SN - 0044-8486

ER -