Ocean urea fertilization for carbon credits poses high ecological risks

Patricia M. Glibert, Rhodora Azanza, Michele Burford, Ken Furuya, Eva Abal, Adnan Al-Azri, Faiza Al-Yamani, Per Andersen, Donald M. Anderson, John Beardall, G. Mine Berg, Larry E Brand, Deborah Bronk, Justin Brookes, JoAnn M. Burkholder, Allan Cembella, William P. Cochlan, Jackie L. Collier, Yves Collos, Robert Diaz & 37 others Martina Doblin, Thomas Drennen, Sonya Dyhrman, Yasuwo Fukuyo, Miles Furnas, James Galloway, Edna Granéli, Dao Viet Ha, Gustaaf Hallegraeff, John Harrison, Paul J. Harrison, Cynthia A. Heil, Kirsten Heimann, Robert Howarth, Cécile Jauzein, Austin A. Kana, Todd M. Kana, Hakgyoon Kim, Raphael Kudela, Catherine Legrand, Michael Mallin, Margaret Mulholland, Shauna Murray, Judith O'Neil, Grant Pitcher, Yuzao Qi, Nancy Rabalais, Robin Raine, Sybil Seitzinger, Paulo S. Salomon, Caroline Solomon, Diane K. Stoecker, Gires Usup, Joanne Wilson, Kedong Yin, Mingjiang Zhou, Mingyuan Zhu

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

40 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The proposed plan for enrichment of the Sulu Sea, Philippines, a region of rich marine biodiversity, with thousands of tonnes of urea in order to stimulate algal blooms and sequester carbon is flawed for multiple reasons. Urea is preferentially used as a nitrogen source by some cyanobacteria and dinoflagellates, many of which are neutrally or positively buoyant. Biological pumps to the deep sea are classically leaky, and the inefficient burial of new biomass makes the estimation of a net loss of carbon from the atmosphere questionable at best. The potential for growth of toxic dinoflagellates is also high, as many grow well on urea and some even increase their toxicity when grown on urea. Many toxic dinoflagellates form cysts which can settle to the sediment and germinate in subsequent years, forming new blooms even without further fertilization. If large-scale blooms do occur, it is likely that they will contribute to hypoxia in the bottom waters upon decomposition. Lastly, urea production requires fossil fuel usage, further limiting the potential for net carbon sequestration. The environmental and economic impacts are potentially great and need to be rigorously assessed.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1049-1056
Number of pages8
JournalMarine Pollution Bulletin
Volume56
Issue number6
DOIs
StatePublished - Jun 1 2008

Fingerprint

carbon markets
Urea
urea
oceans
Carbon
dinoflagellate
carbon
ocean
algal bloom
Philippine Sea
biological pump
Biodiversity
fossil fuels
hypoxia
cyst
economic impact
Fossil fuels
carbon sequestration
algal blooms
pumps

Keywords

  • Carbon credits
  • Carbon sequestration
  • Cyanobacteria
  • Harmful algae
  • Hypoxia
  • Ocean fertilization
  • Sulu Sea
  • Toxic dinoflagellates
  • Urea dumping

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Aquatic Science
  • Oceanography
  • Pollution

Cite this

Glibert, P. M., Azanza, R., Burford, M., Furuya, K., Abal, E., Al-Azri, A., ... Zhu, M. (2008). Ocean urea fertilization for carbon credits poses high ecological risks. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 56(6), 1049-1056. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2008.03.010

Ocean urea fertilization for carbon credits poses high ecological risks. / Glibert, Patricia M.; Azanza, Rhodora; Burford, Michele; Furuya, Ken; Abal, Eva; Al-Azri, Adnan; Al-Yamani, Faiza; Andersen, Per; Anderson, Donald M.; Beardall, John; Berg, G. Mine; Brand, Larry E; Bronk, Deborah; Brookes, Justin; Burkholder, JoAnn M.; Cembella, Allan; Cochlan, William P.; Collier, Jackie L.; Collos, Yves; Diaz, Robert; Doblin, Martina; Drennen, Thomas; Dyhrman, Sonya; Fukuyo, Yasuwo; Furnas, Miles; Galloway, James; Granéli, Edna; Ha, Dao Viet; Hallegraeff, Gustaaf; Harrison, John; Harrison, Paul J.; Heil, Cynthia A.; Heimann, Kirsten; Howarth, Robert; Jauzein, Cécile; Kana, Austin A.; Kana, Todd M.; Kim, Hakgyoon; Kudela, Raphael; Legrand, Catherine; Mallin, Michael; Mulholland, Margaret; Murray, Shauna; O'Neil, Judith; Pitcher, Grant; Qi, Yuzao; Rabalais, Nancy; Raine, Robin; Seitzinger, Sybil; Salomon, Paulo S.; Solomon, Caroline; Stoecker, Diane K.; Usup, Gires; Wilson, Joanne; Yin, Kedong; Zhou, Mingjiang; Zhu, Mingyuan.

In: Marine Pollution Bulletin, Vol. 56, No. 6, 01.06.2008, p. 1049-1056.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Glibert, PM, Azanza, R, Burford, M, Furuya, K, Abal, E, Al-Azri, A, Al-Yamani, F, Andersen, P, Anderson, DM, Beardall, J, Berg, GM, Brand, LE, Bronk, D, Brookes, J, Burkholder, JM, Cembella, A, Cochlan, WP, Collier, JL, Collos, Y, Diaz, R, Doblin, M, Drennen, T, Dyhrman, S, Fukuyo, Y, Furnas, M, Galloway, J, Granéli, E, Ha, DV, Hallegraeff, G, Harrison, J, Harrison, PJ, Heil, CA, Heimann, K, Howarth, R, Jauzein, C, Kana, AA, Kana, TM, Kim, H, Kudela, R, Legrand, C, Mallin, M, Mulholland, M, Murray, S, O'Neil, J, Pitcher, G, Qi, Y, Rabalais, N, Raine, R, Seitzinger, S, Salomon, PS, Solomon, C, Stoecker, DK, Usup, G, Wilson, J, Yin, K, Zhou, M & Zhu, M 2008, 'Ocean urea fertilization for carbon credits poses high ecological risks', Marine Pollution Bulletin, vol. 56, no. 6, pp. 1049-1056. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2008.03.010
Glibert PM, Azanza R, Burford M, Furuya K, Abal E, Al-Azri A et al. Ocean urea fertilization for carbon credits poses high ecological risks. Marine Pollution Bulletin. 2008 Jun 1;56(6):1049-1056. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2008.03.010
Glibert, Patricia M. ; Azanza, Rhodora ; Burford, Michele ; Furuya, Ken ; Abal, Eva ; Al-Azri, Adnan ; Al-Yamani, Faiza ; Andersen, Per ; Anderson, Donald M. ; Beardall, John ; Berg, G. Mine ; Brand, Larry E ; Bronk, Deborah ; Brookes, Justin ; Burkholder, JoAnn M. ; Cembella, Allan ; Cochlan, William P. ; Collier, Jackie L. ; Collos, Yves ; Diaz, Robert ; Doblin, Martina ; Drennen, Thomas ; Dyhrman, Sonya ; Fukuyo, Yasuwo ; Furnas, Miles ; Galloway, James ; Granéli, Edna ; Ha, Dao Viet ; Hallegraeff, Gustaaf ; Harrison, John ; Harrison, Paul J. ; Heil, Cynthia A. ; Heimann, Kirsten ; Howarth, Robert ; Jauzein, Cécile ; Kana, Austin A. ; Kana, Todd M. ; Kim, Hakgyoon ; Kudela, Raphael ; Legrand, Catherine ; Mallin, Michael ; Mulholland, Margaret ; Murray, Shauna ; O'Neil, Judith ; Pitcher, Grant ; Qi, Yuzao ; Rabalais, Nancy ; Raine, Robin ; Seitzinger, Sybil ; Salomon, Paulo S. ; Solomon, Caroline ; Stoecker, Diane K. ; Usup, Gires ; Wilson, Joanne ; Yin, Kedong ; Zhou, Mingjiang ; Zhu, Mingyuan. / Ocean urea fertilization for carbon credits poses high ecological risks. In: Marine Pollution Bulletin. 2008 ; Vol. 56, No. 6. pp. 1049-1056.
@article{6c1adc51a8334bf39411b101697675f5,
title = "Ocean urea fertilization for carbon credits poses high ecological risks",
abstract = "The proposed plan for enrichment of the Sulu Sea, Philippines, a region of rich marine biodiversity, with thousands of tonnes of urea in order to stimulate algal blooms and sequester carbon is flawed for multiple reasons. Urea is preferentially used as a nitrogen source by some cyanobacteria and dinoflagellates, many of which are neutrally or positively buoyant. Biological pumps to the deep sea are classically leaky, and the inefficient burial of new biomass makes the estimation of a net loss of carbon from the atmosphere questionable at best. The potential for growth of toxic dinoflagellates is also high, as many grow well on urea and some even increase their toxicity when grown on urea. Many toxic dinoflagellates form cysts which can settle to the sediment and germinate in subsequent years, forming new blooms even without further fertilization. If large-scale blooms do occur, it is likely that they will contribute to hypoxia in the bottom waters upon decomposition. Lastly, urea production requires fossil fuel usage, further limiting the potential for net carbon sequestration. The environmental and economic impacts are potentially great and need to be rigorously assessed.",
keywords = "Carbon credits, Carbon sequestration, Cyanobacteria, Harmful algae, Hypoxia, Ocean fertilization, Sulu Sea, Toxic dinoflagellates, Urea dumping",
author = "Glibert, {Patricia M.} and Rhodora Azanza and Michele Burford and Ken Furuya and Eva Abal and Adnan Al-Azri and Faiza Al-Yamani and Per Andersen and Anderson, {Donald M.} and John Beardall and Berg, {G. Mine} and Brand, {Larry E} and Deborah Bronk and Justin Brookes and Burkholder, {JoAnn M.} and Allan Cembella and Cochlan, {William P.} and Collier, {Jackie L.} and Yves Collos and Robert Diaz and Martina Doblin and Thomas Drennen and Sonya Dyhrman and Yasuwo Fukuyo and Miles Furnas and James Galloway and Edna Gran{\'e}li and Ha, {Dao Viet} and Gustaaf Hallegraeff and John Harrison and Harrison, {Paul J.} and Heil, {Cynthia A.} and Kirsten Heimann and Robert Howarth and C{\'e}cile Jauzein and Kana, {Austin A.} and Kana, {Todd M.} and Hakgyoon Kim and Raphael Kudela and Catherine Legrand and Michael Mallin and Margaret Mulholland and Shauna Murray and Judith O'Neil and Grant Pitcher and Yuzao Qi and Nancy Rabalais and Robin Raine and Sybil Seitzinger and Salomon, {Paulo S.} and Caroline Solomon and Stoecker, {Diane K.} and Gires Usup and Joanne Wilson and Kedong Yin and Mingjiang Zhou and Mingyuan Zhu",
year = "2008",
month = "6",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.marpolbul.2008.03.010",
language = "English",
volume = "56",
pages = "1049--1056",
journal = "Marine Pollution Bulletin",
issn = "0025-326X",
publisher = "Elsevier Inc.",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Ocean urea fertilization for carbon credits poses high ecological risks

AU - Glibert, Patricia M.

AU - Azanza, Rhodora

AU - Burford, Michele

AU - Furuya, Ken

AU - Abal, Eva

AU - Al-Azri, Adnan

AU - Al-Yamani, Faiza

AU - Andersen, Per

AU - Anderson, Donald M.

AU - Beardall, John

AU - Berg, G. Mine

AU - Brand, Larry E

AU - Bronk, Deborah

AU - Brookes, Justin

AU - Burkholder, JoAnn M.

AU - Cembella, Allan

AU - Cochlan, William P.

AU - Collier, Jackie L.

AU - Collos, Yves

AU - Diaz, Robert

AU - Doblin, Martina

AU - Drennen, Thomas

AU - Dyhrman, Sonya

AU - Fukuyo, Yasuwo

AU - Furnas, Miles

AU - Galloway, James

AU - Granéli, Edna

AU - Ha, Dao Viet

AU - Hallegraeff, Gustaaf

AU - Harrison, John

AU - Harrison, Paul J.

AU - Heil, Cynthia A.

AU - Heimann, Kirsten

AU - Howarth, Robert

AU - Jauzein, Cécile

AU - Kana, Austin A.

AU - Kana, Todd M.

AU - Kim, Hakgyoon

AU - Kudela, Raphael

AU - Legrand, Catherine

AU - Mallin, Michael

AU - Mulholland, Margaret

AU - Murray, Shauna

AU - O'Neil, Judith

AU - Pitcher, Grant

AU - Qi, Yuzao

AU - Rabalais, Nancy

AU - Raine, Robin

AU - Seitzinger, Sybil

AU - Salomon, Paulo S.

AU - Solomon, Caroline

AU - Stoecker, Diane K.

AU - Usup, Gires

AU - Wilson, Joanne

AU - Yin, Kedong

AU - Zhou, Mingjiang

AU - Zhu, Mingyuan

PY - 2008/6/1

Y1 - 2008/6/1

N2 - The proposed plan for enrichment of the Sulu Sea, Philippines, a region of rich marine biodiversity, with thousands of tonnes of urea in order to stimulate algal blooms and sequester carbon is flawed for multiple reasons. Urea is preferentially used as a nitrogen source by some cyanobacteria and dinoflagellates, many of which are neutrally or positively buoyant. Biological pumps to the deep sea are classically leaky, and the inefficient burial of new biomass makes the estimation of a net loss of carbon from the atmosphere questionable at best. The potential for growth of toxic dinoflagellates is also high, as many grow well on urea and some even increase their toxicity when grown on urea. Many toxic dinoflagellates form cysts which can settle to the sediment and germinate in subsequent years, forming new blooms even without further fertilization. If large-scale blooms do occur, it is likely that they will contribute to hypoxia in the bottom waters upon decomposition. Lastly, urea production requires fossil fuel usage, further limiting the potential for net carbon sequestration. The environmental and economic impacts are potentially great and need to be rigorously assessed.

AB - The proposed plan for enrichment of the Sulu Sea, Philippines, a region of rich marine biodiversity, with thousands of tonnes of urea in order to stimulate algal blooms and sequester carbon is flawed for multiple reasons. Urea is preferentially used as a nitrogen source by some cyanobacteria and dinoflagellates, many of which are neutrally or positively buoyant. Biological pumps to the deep sea are classically leaky, and the inefficient burial of new biomass makes the estimation of a net loss of carbon from the atmosphere questionable at best. The potential for growth of toxic dinoflagellates is also high, as many grow well on urea and some even increase their toxicity when grown on urea. Many toxic dinoflagellates form cysts which can settle to the sediment and germinate in subsequent years, forming new blooms even without further fertilization. If large-scale blooms do occur, it is likely that they will contribute to hypoxia in the bottom waters upon decomposition. Lastly, urea production requires fossil fuel usage, further limiting the potential for net carbon sequestration. The environmental and economic impacts are potentially great and need to be rigorously assessed.

KW - Carbon credits

KW - Carbon sequestration

KW - Cyanobacteria

KW - Harmful algae

KW - Hypoxia

KW - Ocean fertilization

KW - Sulu Sea

KW - Toxic dinoflagellates

KW - Urea dumping

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=44649194542&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=44649194542&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.marpolbul.2008.03.010

DO - 10.1016/j.marpolbul.2008.03.010

M3 - Article

VL - 56

SP - 1049

EP - 1056

JO - Marine Pollution Bulletin

JF - Marine Pollution Bulletin

SN - 0025-326X

IS - 6

ER -