Neurologic deterioration secondary to unrecognized spinal instability following trauma - A multicenter study

Allan D Levi, R. John Hurlbert, Paul Anderson, Michael Fehlings, Raj Rampersaud, Eric M. Massicotte, John C. France, Jean Charles Le Huec, Rune Hedlund, Paul Arnold

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

69 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

STUDY DESIGN.: A retrospective study was undertaken that evaluated the medical records and imaging studies of a subset of patients with spinal injury from large level I trauma centers. OBJECTIVE.: To characterize patients with spinal injuries who had neurologic deterioration due to unrecognized instability. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA.: Controversy exists regarding the most appropriate imaging studies required to "clear" the spine in patients suspected of having a spinal column injury. Although most bony and/or ligamentous spine injuries are detected early, an occasional patient has an occult injury, which is not detected, and a potentially straightforward problem becomes a neurologic catastrophe. METHODS.: The study was designed as a retrospective review of patients who had neurologic deterioration as a direct result of an unrecognized fracture, subluxation, or soft tissue injury of the cervical, thoracic, or lumbar spine from 8 level I trauma centers. Demographics, injury information, and neurologic outcome were collected. The etiology and incidence of the missed injury were determined. RESULTS.: A total of 24 patients were identified who were treated or referred to 1 of the participating trauma centers and had an adverse neurologic outcome as a result of the missed injury. The average age of the patientswas 50 years (range 18-92), and average delay in diagnosis was 19.8 days. Radiculopathy developed in 5 patients, 16 had spinal cord injuries, and 3 patients died as a result oftheir neurologic injury. The most common reason for the missed injury was insufficient imaging studies (58.3%), while only 33.3% were a result of misread radiographs or 8.3% poor quality radiographs. The incidence of missed injuries resulting in neurologic injury in patients with spine fractures or strains was 0.21%, and the incidence as a percentage of all trauma patients evaluated was 0.025%. CONCLUSIONS.: This multicenter study establishes that missed spinal injuries resulting in a neurologic deficit continue to occur in major trauma centers despite the presence of experienced personnel and sophisticated imaging techniques. Older age, high impact accidents, and patients with insufficient imaging are at highest risk.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)451-458
Number of pages8
JournalSpine
Volume31
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 1 2006

Fingerprint

Nervous System
Multicenter Studies
Wounds and Injuries
Spinal Injuries
Trauma Centers
Spine
Nervous System Trauma
Incidence
Soft Tissue Injuries
Radiculopathy
Diagnostic Imaging
Neurologic Manifestations
Spinal Cord Injuries
Accidents
Medical Records
Thorax
Retrospective Studies
Demography

Keywords

  • Radiculopathy
  • Spinal clearance
  • Spinal cord injury
  • Spinal instability
  • Trauma

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Physiology
  • Clinical Neurology
  • Orthopedics and Sports Medicine

Cite this

Levi, A. D., Hurlbert, R. J., Anderson, P., Fehlings, M., Rampersaud, R., Massicotte, E. M., ... Arnold, P. (2006). Neurologic deterioration secondary to unrecognized spinal instability following trauma - A multicenter study. Spine, 31(4), 451-458. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.brs.0000199927.78531.b5

Neurologic deterioration secondary to unrecognized spinal instability following trauma - A multicenter study. / Levi, Allan D; Hurlbert, R. John; Anderson, Paul; Fehlings, Michael; Rampersaud, Raj; Massicotte, Eric M.; France, John C.; Le Huec, Jean Charles; Hedlund, Rune; Arnold, Paul.

In: Spine, Vol. 31, No. 4, 01.02.2006, p. 451-458.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Levi, AD, Hurlbert, RJ, Anderson, P, Fehlings, M, Rampersaud, R, Massicotte, EM, France, JC, Le Huec, JC, Hedlund, R & Arnold, P 2006, 'Neurologic deterioration secondary to unrecognized spinal instability following trauma - A multicenter study', Spine, vol. 31, no. 4, pp. 451-458. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.brs.0000199927.78531.b5
Levi, Allan D ; Hurlbert, R. John ; Anderson, Paul ; Fehlings, Michael ; Rampersaud, Raj ; Massicotte, Eric M. ; France, John C. ; Le Huec, Jean Charles ; Hedlund, Rune ; Arnold, Paul. / Neurologic deterioration secondary to unrecognized spinal instability following trauma - A multicenter study. In: Spine. 2006 ; Vol. 31, No. 4. pp. 451-458.
@article{f110835984474ce898a98d82565393fe,
title = "Neurologic deterioration secondary to unrecognized spinal instability following trauma - A multicenter study",
abstract = "STUDY DESIGN.: A retrospective study was undertaken that evaluated the medical records and imaging studies of a subset of patients with spinal injury from large level I trauma centers. OBJECTIVE.: To characterize patients with spinal injuries who had neurologic deterioration due to unrecognized instability. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA.: Controversy exists regarding the most appropriate imaging studies required to {"}clear{"} the spine in patients suspected of having a spinal column injury. Although most bony and/or ligamentous spine injuries are detected early, an occasional patient has an occult injury, which is not detected, and a potentially straightforward problem becomes a neurologic catastrophe. METHODS.: The study was designed as a retrospective review of patients who had neurologic deterioration as a direct result of an unrecognized fracture, subluxation, or soft tissue injury of the cervical, thoracic, or lumbar spine from 8 level I trauma centers. Demographics, injury information, and neurologic outcome were collected. The etiology and incidence of the missed injury were determined. RESULTS.: A total of 24 patients were identified who were treated or referred to 1 of the participating trauma centers and had an adverse neurologic outcome as a result of the missed injury. The average age of the patientswas 50 years (range 18-92), and average delay in diagnosis was 19.8 days. Radiculopathy developed in 5 patients, 16 had spinal cord injuries, and 3 patients died as a result oftheir neurologic injury. The most common reason for the missed injury was insufficient imaging studies (58.3{\%}), while only 33.3{\%} were a result of misread radiographs or 8.3{\%} poor quality radiographs. The incidence of missed injuries resulting in neurologic injury in patients with spine fractures or strains was 0.21{\%}, and the incidence as a percentage of all trauma patients evaluated was 0.025{\%}. CONCLUSIONS.: This multicenter study establishes that missed spinal injuries resulting in a neurologic deficit continue to occur in major trauma centers despite the presence of experienced personnel and sophisticated imaging techniques. Older age, high impact accidents, and patients with insufficient imaging are at highest risk.",
keywords = "Radiculopathy, Spinal clearance, Spinal cord injury, Spinal instability, Trauma",
author = "Levi, {Allan D} and Hurlbert, {R. John} and Paul Anderson and Michael Fehlings and Raj Rampersaud and Massicotte, {Eric M.} and France, {John C.} and {Le Huec}, {Jean Charles} and Rune Hedlund and Paul Arnold",
year = "2006",
month = "2",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1097/01.brs.0000199927.78531.b5",
language = "English",
volume = "31",
pages = "451--458",
journal = "Spine",
issn = "0362-2436",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Neurologic deterioration secondary to unrecognized spinal instability following trauma - A multicenter study

AU - Levi, Allan D

AU - Hurlbert, R. John

AU - Anderson, Paul

AU - Fehlings, Michael

AU - Rampersaud, Raj

AU - Massicotte, Eric M.

AU - France, John C.

AU - Le Huec, Jean Charles

AU - Hedlund, Rune

AU - Arnold, Paul

PY - 2006/2/1

Y1 - 2006/2/1

N2 - STUDY DESIGN.: A retrospective study was undertaken that evaluated the medical records and imaging studies of a subset of patients with spinal injury from large level I trauma centers. OBJECTIVE.: To characterize patients with spinal injuries who had neurologic deterioration due to unrecognized instability. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA.: Controversy exists regarding the most appropriate imaging studies required to "clear" the spine in patients suspected of having a spinal column injury. Although most bony and/or ligamentous spine injuries are detected early, an occasional patient has an occult injury, which is not detected, and a potentially straightforward problem becomes a neurologic catastrophe. METHODS.: The study was designed as a retrospective review of patients who had neurologic deterioration as a direct result of an unrecognized fracture, subluxation, or soft tissue injury of the cervical, thoracic, or lumbar spine from 8 level I trauma centers. Demographics, injury information, and neurologic outcome were collected. The etiology and incidence of the missed injury were determined. RESULTS.: A total of 24 patients were identified who were treated or referred to 1 of the participating trauma centers and had an adverse neurologic outcome as a result of the missed injury. The average age of the patientswas 50 years (range 18-92), and average delay in diagnosis was 19.8 days. Radiculopathy developed in 5 patients, 16 had spinal cord injuries, and 3 patients died as a result oftheir neurologic injury. The most common reason for the missed injury was insufficient imaging studies (58.3%), while only 33.3% were a result of misread radiographs or 8.3% poor quality radiographs. The incidence of missed injuries resulting in neurologic injury in patients with spine fractures or strains was 0.21%, and the incidence as a percentage of all trauma patients evaluated was 0.025%. CONCLUSIONS.: This multicenter study establishes that missed spinal injuries resulting in a neurologic deficit continue to occur in major trauma centers despite the presence of experienced personnel and sophisticated imaging techniques. Older age, high impact accidents, and patients with insufficient imaging are at highest risk.

AB - STUDY DESIGN.: A retrospective study was undertaken that evaluated the medical records and imaging studies of a subset of patients with spinal injury from large level I trauma centers. OBJECTIVE.: To characterize patients with spinal injuries who had neurologic deterioration due to unrecognized instability. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA.: Controversy exists regarding the most appropriate imaging studies required to "clear" the spine in patients suspected of having a spinal column injury. Although most bony and/or ligamentous spine injuries are detected early, an occasional patient has an occult injury, which is not detected, and a potentially straightforward problem becomes a neurologic catastrophe. METHODS.: The study was designed as a retrospective review of patients who had neurologic deterioration as a direct result of an unrecognized fracture, subluxation, or soft tissue injury of the cervical, thoracic, or lumbar spine from 8 level I trauma centers. Demographics, injury information, and neurologic outcome were collected. The etiology and incidence of the missed injury were determined. RESULTS.: A total of 24 patients were identified who were treated or referred to 1 of the participating trauma centers and had an adverse neurologic outcome as a result of the missed injury. The average age of the patientswas 50 years (range 18-92), and average delay in diagnosis was 19.8 days. Radiculopathy developed in 5 patients, 16 had spinal cord injuries, and 3 patients died as a result oftheir neurologic injury. The most common reason for the missed injury was insufficient imaging studies (58.3%), while only 33.3% were a result of misread radiographs or 8.3% poor quality radiographs. The incidence of missed injuries resulting in neurologic injury in patients with spine fractures or strains was 0.21%, and the incidence as a percentage of all trauma patients evaluated was 0.025%. CONCLUSIONS.: This multicenter study establishes that missed spinal injuries resulting in a neurologic deficit continue to occur in major trauma centers despite the presence of experienced personnel and sophisticated imaging techniques. Older age, high impact accidents, and patients with insufficient imaging are at highest risk.

KW - Radiculopathy

KW - Spinal clearance

KW - Spinal cord injury

KW - Spinal instability

KW - Trauma

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33644839813&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33644839813&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1097/01.brs.0000199927.78531.b5

DO - 10.1097/01.brs.0000199927.78531.b5

M3 - Article

C2 - 16481957

AN - SCOPUS:33644839813

VL - 31

SP - 451

EP - 458

JO - Spine

JF - Spine

SN - 0362-2436

IS - 4

ER -