Evolutionary stability of mutualism: Interspecific population regulation as an evolutionary stable strategy

J. Nathaniel Holland, Donald L. DeAngelis, Stewart T. Schultz

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

57 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Interspecific mutualisms are often vulnerable to instability because low benefit: cost ratios can rapidly lead to extinction or to the conversion of mutualism to parasite-host or predator-prey interactions. We hypothesize that the evolutionary stability of mutualism can depend on how benefits and costs to one mutualist vary with the population density of its partner, and that stability can be maintained if a mutualist can influence demographic rates and regulate the population density of its partner. We test this hypothesis in a model of mutualism with key features of senita cactus (Pachycereus schottii) - senita moth (Upiga virescens) interactions, in which benefits of pollination and costs of larval seed consumption to plant fitness depend on pollinator density. We show that plants can maximize their fitness by allocating resources to the production of excess flowers at the expense of fruit. Fruit abortion resulting from excess flower production reduces pre-adult survival of the pollinating seed-consumer, and maintains its density beneath a threshold that would destabilize the mutualism. Such a strategy of excess flower production and fruit abortion is convergent and evolutionarily stable against invasion by cheater plants that produce few flowers and abort few to no fruit. This novel mechanism of achieving evolutionarily stable mutualism, namely interspecific population regulation, is qualitatively different from other mechanisms invoking partner choice or selective rewards, and may be a general process that helps to preserve mutualistic interactions in nature.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1807-1814
Number of pages8
JournalProceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
Volume271
Issue number1550
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 7 2004

Fingerprint

population regulation
Symbiosis
mutualism
Fruits
Fruit
flower
fruit
Cost-Benefit Analysis
flowers
abortion (plants)
Population
Seed
Population Density
Pachycereus schottii
Seeds
pollination
population density
Costs
fitness
Cactaceae

Keywords

  • Fruit abortion
  • Hermaphrodite
  • Pollination
  • Population dynamics
  • Resource trade-offs
  • Sex allocation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Agricultural and Biological Sciences(all)
  • Agricultural and Biological Sciences (miscellaneous)

Cite this

Evolutionary stability of mutualism : Interspecific population regulation as an evolutionary stable strategy. / Holland, J. Nathaniel; DeAngelis, Donald L.; Schultz, Stewart T.

In: Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, Vol. 271, No. 1550, 07.09.2004, p. 1807-1814.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Holland, J. Nathaniel ; DeAngelis, Donald L. ; Schultz, Stewart T. / Evolutionary stability of mutualism : Interspecific population regulation as an evolutionary stable strategy. In: Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 2004 ; Vol. 271, No. 1550. pp. 1807-1814.
@article{464e687af743413da93df28e742fa590,
title = "Evolutionary stability of mutualism: Interspecific population regulation as an evolutionary stable strategy",
abstract = "Interspecific mutualisms are often vulnerable to instability because low benefit: cost ratios can rapidly lead to extinction or to the conversion of mutualism to parasite-host or predator-prey interactions. We hypothesize that the evolutionary stability of mutualism can depend on how benefits and costs to one mutualist vary with the population density of its partner, and that stability can be maintained if a mutualist can influence demographic rates and regulate the population density of its partner. We test this hypothesis in a model of mutualism with key features of senita cactus (Pachycereus schottii) - senita moth (Upiga virescens) interactions, in which benefits of pollination and costs of larval seed consumption to plant fitness depend on pollinator density. We show that plants can maximize their fitness by allocating resources to the production of excess flowers at the expense of fruit. Fruit abortion resulting from excess flower production reduces pre-adult survival of the pollinating seed-consumer, and maintains its density beneath a threshold that would destabilize the mutualism. Such a strategy of excess flower production and fruit abortion is convergent and evolutionarily stable against invasion by cheater plants that produce few flowers and abort few to no fruit. This novel mechanism of achieving evolutionarily stable mutualism, namely interspecific population regulation, is qualitatively different from other mechanisms invoking partner choice or selective rewards, and may be a general process that helps to preserve mutualistic interactions in nature.",
keywords = "Fruit abortion, Hermaphrodite, Pollination, Population dynamics, Resource trade-offs, Sex allocation",
author = "Holland, {J. Nathaniel} and DeAngelis, {Donald L.} and Schultz, {Stewart T.}",
year = "2004",
month = "9",
day = "7",
doi = "10.1098/rspb.2004.2789",
language = "English",
volume = "271",
pages = "1807--1814",
journal = "Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences",
issn = "0800-4622",
publisher = "Royal Society of London",
number = "1550",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Evolutionary stability of mutualism

T2 - Interspecific population regulation as an evolutionary stable strategy

AU - Holland, J. Nathaniel

AU - DeAngelis, Donald L.

AU - Schultz, Stewart T.

PY - 2004/9/7

Y1 - 2004/9/7

N2 - Interspecific mutualisms are often vulnerable to instability because low benefit: cost ratios can rapidly lead to extinction or to the conversion of mutualism to parasite-host or predator-prey interactions. We hypothesize that the evolutionary stability of mutualism can depend on how benefits and costs to one mutualist vary with the population density of its partner, and that stability can be maintained if a mutualist can influence demographic rates and regulate the population density of its partner. We test this hypothesis in a model of mutualism with key features of senita cactus (Pachycereus schottii) - senita moth (Upiga virescens) interactions, in which benefits of pollination and costs of larval seed consumption to plant fitness depend on pollinator density. We show that plants can maximize their fitness by allocating resources to the production of excess flowers at the expense of fruit. Fruit abortion resulting from excess flower production reduces pre-adult survival of the pollinating seed-consumer, and maintains its density beneath a threshold that would destabilize the mutualism. Such a strategy of excess flower production and fruit abortion is convergent and evolutionarily stable against invasion by cheater plants that produce few flowers and abort few to no fruit. This novel mechanism of achieving evolutionarily stable mutualism, namely interspecific population regulation, is qualitatively different from other mechanisms invoking partner choice or selective rewards, and may be a general process that helps to preserve mutualistic interactions in nature.

AB - Interspecific mutualisms are often vulnerable to instability because low benefit: cost ratios can rapidly lead to extinction or to the conversion of mutualism to parasite-host or predator-prey interactions. We hypothesize that the evolutionary stability of mutualism can depend on how benefits and costs to one mutualist vary with the population density of its partner, and that stability can be maintained if a mutualist can influence demographic rates and regulate the population density of its partner. We test this hypothesis in a model of mutualism with key features of senita cactus (Pachycereus schottii) - senita moth (Upiga virescens) interactions, in which benefits of pollination and costs of larval seed consumption to plant fitness depend on pollinator density. We show that plants can maximize their fitness by allocating resources to the production of excess flowers at the expense of fruit. Fruit abortion resulting from excess flower production reduces pre-adult survival of the pollinating seed-consumer, and maintains its density beneath a threshold that would destabilize the mutualism. Such a strategy of excess flower production and fruit abortion is convergent and evolutionarily stable against invasion by cheater plants that produce few flowers and abort few to no fruit. This novel mechanism of achieving evolutionarily stable mutualism, namely interspecific population regulation, is qualitatively different from other mechanisms invoking partner choice or selective rewards, and may be a general process that helps to preserve mutualistic interactions in nature.

KW - Fruit abortion

KW - Hermaphrodite

KW - Pollination

KW - Population dynamics

KW - Resource trade-offs

KW - Sex allocation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=17044431840&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=17044431840&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1098/rspb.2004.2789

DO - 10.1098/rspb.2004.2789

M3 - Article

C2 - 15315896

AN - SCOPUS:17044431840

VL - 271

SP - 1807

EP - 1814

JO - Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences

JF - Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences

SN - 0800-4622

IS - 1550

ER -