Efficacy, safety and tolerability of an optimized avulsion technique with Onyster® (40% urea ointment with plastic dressing) ointment compared to bifonazole-urea ointment for removal of the clinically infected nail in toenail onychomycosis: A randomized evaluator-blinded controlled study

M. Lahfa, C. Bulai-Livideanu, R. Baran, J. P. Ortonne, B. Richert, Antonella Tosti, B. M. Piraccini, J. C. Szepietowski, V. Sibaud, H. Coubetergues, J. J. Voisard, C. Paul

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

15 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: Toenail onychomycosis is highly prevalent, with 14-28% of people aged 60 or over suffering from the disease. Use of a topical antifungal alone in toenail onychomycosis is associated with low cure rates. This may be due to limited penetration of the topical antifungal through the diseased nail. The objective of the present study was to compare two treatment modalities to obtain diseased nail chemical avulsion in toenail onychomycosis. Methods: In this European, multicenter, randomized, parallel-group, open-label, active-controlled study, male or female adult patients with distal-lateral or lateral subungual dermatophyte onychomycosis on at least 12.5% of the great toenail were randomized either to a 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing group (n = 53) or to a bifonazole-urea ointment group (n = 52). The ointments were applied daily for a maximum of 3 weeks according to the summary of product characteristics. After assessment of infected nail debridement, topical antifungal treatment with bifonazole cream was applied daily in both groups for 8 weeks. 102 patients were evaluated, i.e. 51 in the 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing group and 51 in the bifonazole-urea group. The primary end point was complete removal of the nail plate at day 21 (D21). Secondary end points were: complete cure and mycological cure evaluated at D105. Ease of use and local tolerability were also assessed. Results: Complete removal of the clinically infected target nail plate area, assessed by blinded evaluators, was significantly higher in the 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing group (61.2%) than in the control group (39.2%), showing the superiority of 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing (p = 0.028). The same results were observed in the per-protocol population (63.0 vs. 36.6%; p = 0.014). Complete removal of the infected area assessed by the investigator at D21 showed a significantly higher success rate in patients treated with 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing (86.3%) as compared to patients treated with bifonazole-urea (60.8%), confirming the superiority of 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing (p = 0.004). At D105, the complete cure of onychomycosis, a criterion combining clinical and mycological assessments, showed a success rate of 27.7% for 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing versus 20.8% for the control group. No statistical difference was observed between the two treatment groups. The number of patients with at least one adverse event was twice as high in the bifonazole-urea group in comparison to the 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing group. Overall assessment of local tolerability by the investigator was considered good/very good in 98.0% of the 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing patients versus 90.4% of the bifonazole-urea patients, at D21, with no significant difference between both groups. Conclusion: This study shows the superiority of 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing to bifonazole-urea ointment for complete removal of the infected target nail assessed by blinded evaluators and by the investigators. Further studies are needed to assess the impact of preliminary chemical nail avulsion on the efficacy of topical treatment of onychomycosis as assessed by complete cure at 1 year.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)5-12
Number of pages8
JournalDermatology
Volume226
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - May 1 2013
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

bifonazole
Onychomycosis
Bandages
Ointments
Nails
Plastics
Urea
Safety
Nail Diseases
Research Personnel

Keywords

  • Chemical avulsion
  • Onychomycosis
  • Randomized controlled trial
  • Urea

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Dermatology

Cite this

Efficacy, safety and tolerability of an optimized avulsion technique with Onyster® (40% urea ointment with plastic dressing) ointment compared to bifonazole-urea ointment for removal of the clinically infected nail in toenail onychomycosis : A randomized evaluator-blinded controlled study. / Lahfa, M.; Bulai-Livideanu, C.; Baran, R.; Ortonne, J. P.; Richert, B.; Tosti, Antonella; Piraccini, B. M.; Szepietowski, J. C.; Sibaud, V.; Coubetergues, H.; Voisard, J. J.; Paul, C.

In: Dermatology, Vol. 226, No. 1, 01.05.2013, p. 5-12.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Lahfa, M. ; Bulai-Livideanu, C. ; Baran, R. ; Ortonne, J. P. ; Richert, B. ; Tosti, Antonella ; Piraccini, B. M. ; Szepietowski, J. C. ; Sibaud, V. ; Coubetergues, H. ; Voisard, J. J. ; Paul, C. / Efficacy, safety and tolerability of an optimized avulsion technique with Onyster® (40% urea ointment with plastic dressing) ointment compared to bifonazole-urea ointment for removal of the clinically infected nail in toenail onychomycosis : A randomized evaluator-blinded controlled study. In: Dermatology. 2013 ; Vol. 226, No. 1. pp. 5-12.
@article{efd5e36004f442e49d4c4a017058b353,
title = "Efficacy, safety and tolerability of an optimized avulsion technique with Onyster{\circledR} (40{\%} urea ointment with plastic dressing) ointment compared to bifonazole-urea ointment for removal of the clinically infected nail in toenail onychomycosis: A randomized evaluator-blinded controlled study",
abstract = "Background: Toenail onychomycosis is highly prevalent, with 14-28{\%} of people aged 60 or over suffering from the disease. Use of a topical antifungal alone in toenail onychomycosis is associated with low cure rates. This may be due to limited penetration of the topical antifungal through the diseased nail. The objective of the present study was to compare two treatment modalities to obtain diseased nail chemical avulsion in toenail onychomycosis. Methods: In this European, multicenter, randomized, parallel-group, open-label, active-controlled study, male or female adult patients with distal-lateral or lateral subungual dermatophyte onychomycosis on at least 12.5{\%} of the great toenail were randomized either to a 40{\%} urea ointment with plastic dressing group (n = 53) or to a bifonazole-urea ointment group (n = 52). The ointments were applied daily for a maximum of 3 weeks according to the summary of product characteristics. After assessment of infected nail debridement, topical antifungal treatment with bifonazole cream was applied daily in both groups for 8 weeks. 102 patients were evaluated, i.e. 51 in the 40{\%} urea ointment with plastic dressing group and 51 in the bifonazole-urea group. The primary end point was complete removal of the nail plate at day 21 (D21). Secondary end points were: complete cure and mycological cure evaluated at D105. Ease of use and local tolerability were also assessed. Results: Complete removal of the clinically infected target nail plate area, assessed by blinded evaluators, was significantly higher in the 40{\%} urea ointment with plastic dressing group (61.2{\%}) than in the control group (39.2{\%}), showing the superiority of 40{\%} urea ointment with plastic dressing (p = 0.028). The same results were observed in the per-protocol population (63.0 vs. 36.6{\%}; p = 0.014). Complete removal of the infected area assessed by the investigator at D21 showed a significantly higher success rate in patients treated with 40{\%} urea ointment with plastic dressing (86.3{\%}) as compared to patients treated with bifonazole-urea (60.8{\%}), confirming the superiority of 40{\%} urea ointment with plastic dressing (p = 0.004). At D105, the complete cure of onychomycosis, a criterion combining clinical and mycological assessments, showed a success rate of 27.7{\%} for 40{\%} urea ointment with plastic dressing versus 20.8{\%} for the control group. No statistical difference was observed between the two treatment groups. The number of patients with at least one adverse event was twice as high in the bifonazole-urea group in comparison to the 40{\%} urea ointment with plastic dressing group. Overall assessment of local tolerability by the investigator was considered good/very good in 98.0{\%} of the 40{\%} urea ointment with plastic dressing patients versus 90.4{\%} of the bifonazole-urea patients, at D21, with no significant difference between both groups. Conclusion: This study shows the superiority of 40{\%} urea ointment with plastic dressing to bifonazole-urea ointment for complete removal of the infected target nail assessed by blinded evaluators and by the investigators. Further studies are needed to assess the impact of preliminary chemical nail avulsion on the efficacy of topical treatment of onychomycosis as assessed by complete cure at 1 year.",
keywords = "Chemical avulsion, Onychomycosis, Randomized controlled trial, Urea",
author = "M. Lahfa and C. Bulai-Livideanu and R. Baran and Ortonne, {J. P.} and B. Richert and Antonella Tosti and Piraccini, {B. M.} and Szepietowski, {J. C.} and V. Sibaud and H. Coubetergues and Voisard, {J. J.} and C. Paul",
year = "2013",
month = "5",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1159/000345105",
language = "English",
volume = "226",
pages = "5--12",
journal = "Dermatology",
issn = "1018-8665",
publisher = "S. Karger AG",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Efficacy, safety and tolerability of an optimized avulsion technique with Onyster® (40% urea ointment with plastic dressing) ointment compared to bifonazole-urea ointment for removal of the clinically infected nail in toenail onychomycosis

T2 - A randomized evaluator-blinded controlled study

AU - Lahfa, M.

AU - Bulai-Livideanu, C.

AU - Baran, R.

AU - Ortonne, J. P.

AU - Richert, B.

AU - Tosti, Antonella

AU - Piraccini, B. M.

AU - Szepietowski, J. C.

AU - Sibaud, V.

AU - Coubetergues, H.

AU - Voisard, J. J.

AU - Paul, C.

PY - 2013/5/1

Y1 - 2013/5/1

N2 - Background: Toenail onychomycosis is highly prevalent, with 14-28% of people aged 60 or over suffering from the disease. Use of a topical antifungal alone in toenail onychomycosis is associated with low cure rates. This may be due to limited penetration of the topical antifungal through the diseased nail. The objective of the present study was to compare two treatment modalities to obtain diseased nail chemical avulsion in toenail onychomycosis. Methods: In this European, multicenter, randomized, parallel-group, open-label, active-controlled study, male or female adult patients with distal-lateral or lateral subungual dermatophyte onychomycosis on at least 12.5% of the great toenail were randomized either to a 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing group (n = 53) or to a bifonazole-urea ointment group (n = 52). The ointments were applied daily for a maximum of 3 weeks according to the summary of product characteristics. After assessment of infected nail debridement, topical antifungal treatment with bifonazole cream was applied daily in both groups for 8 weeks. 102 patients were evaluated, i.e. 51 in the 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing group and 51 in the bifonazole-urea group. The primary end point was complete removal of the nail plate at day 21 (D21). Secondary end points were: complete cure and mycological cure evaluated at D105. Ease of use and local tolerability were also assessed. Results: Complete removal of the clinically infected target nail plate area, assessed by blinded evaluators, was significantly higher in the 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing group (61.2%) than in the control group (39.2%), showing the superiority of 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing (p = 0.028). The same results were observed in the per-protocol population (63.0 vs. 36.6%; p = 0.014). Complete removal of the infected area assessed by the investigator at D21 showed a significantly higher success rate in patients treated with 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing (86.3%) as compared to patients treated with bifonazole-urea (60.8%), confirming the superiority of 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing (p = 0.004). At D105, the complete cure of onychomycosis, a criterion combining clinical and mycological assessments, showed a success rate of 27.7% for 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing versus 20.8% for the control group. No statistical difference was observed between the two treatment groups. The number of patients with at least one adverse event was twice as high in the bifonazole-urea group in comparison to the 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing group. Overall assessment of local tolerability by the investigator was considered good/very good in 98.0% of the 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing patients versus 90.4% of the bifonazole-urea patients, at D21, with no significant difference between both groups. Conclusion: This study shows the superiority of 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing to bifonazole-urea ointment for complete removal of the infected target nail assessed by blinded evaluators and by the investigators. Further studies are needed to assess the impact of preliminary chemical nail avulsion on the efficacy of topical treatment of onychomycosis as assessed by complete cure at 1 year.

AB - Background: Toenail onychomycosis is highly prevalent, with 14-28% of people aged 60 or over suffering from the disease. Use of a topical antifungal alone in toenail onychomycosis is associated with low cure rates. This may be due to limited penetration of the topical antifungal through the diseased nail. The objective of the present study was to compare two treatment modalities to obtain diseased nail chemical avulsion in toenail onychomycosis. Methods: In this European, multicenter, randomized, parallel-group, open-label, active-controlled study, male or female adult patients with distal-lateral or lateral subungual dermatophyte onychomycosis on at least 12.5% of the great toenail were randomized either to a 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing group (n = 53) or to a bifonazole-urea ointment group (n = 52). The ointments were applied daily for a maximum of 3 weeks according to the summary of product characteristics. After assessment of infected nail debridement, topical antifungal treatment with bifonazole cream was applied daily in both groups for 8 weeks. 102 patients were evaluated, i.e. 51 in the 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing group and 51 in the bifonazole-urea group. The primary end point was complete removal of the nail plate at day 21 (D21). Secondary end points were: complete cure and mycological cure evaluated at D105. Ease of use and local tolerability were also assessed. Results: Complete removal of the clinically infected target nail plate area, assessed by blinded evaluators, was significantly higher in the 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing group (61.2%) than in the control group (39.2%), showing the superiority of 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing (p = 0.028). The same results were observed in the per-protocol population (63.0 vs. 36.6%; p = 0.014). Complete removal of the infected area assessed by the investigator at D21 showed a significantly higher success rate in patients treated with 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing (86.3%) as compared to patients treated with bifonazole-urea (60.8%), confirming the superiority of 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing (p = 0.004). At D105, the complete cure of onychomycosis, a criterion combining clinical and mycological assessments, showed a success rate of 27.7% for 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing versus 20.8% for the control group. No statistical difference was observed between the two treatment groups. The number of patients with at least one adverse event was twice as high in the bifonazole-urea group in comparison to the 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing group. Overall assessment of local tolerability by the investigator was considered good/very good in 98.0% of the 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing patients versus 90.4% of the bifonazole-urea patients, at D21, with no significant difference between both groups. Conclusion: This study shows the superiority of 40% urea ointment with plastic dressing to bifonazole-urea ointment for complete removal of the infected target nail assessed by blinded evaluators and by the investigators. Further studies are needed to assess the impact of preliminary chemical nail avulsion on the efficacy of topical treatment of onychomycosis as assessed by complete cure at 1 year.

KW - Chemical avulsion

KW - Onychomycosis

KW - Randomized controlled trial

KW - Urea

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84878020879&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84878020879&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1159/000345105

DO - 10.1159/000345105

M3 - Article

C2 - 23467055

AN - SCOPUS:84878020879

VL - 226

SP - 5

EP - 12

JO - Dermatology

JF - Dermatology

SN - 1018-8665

IS - 1

ER -