Education and cultural transmission/transformation. philosophical reflections on the historian's task

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

9 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Education seems obviously to be a cause of the transmission—and sometimes, of the transformation—of culture. Understanding this causal interaction is difficult, in part because “education” and “culture” are notoriously difficult to characterize with precision; and in part because the causal interaction goes in both directions: Culture has a causal impact on education that is apparently as great as, or perhaps even greater than, the causal impact of education on culture. How can we best understand the nature of this complex causal interaction? In this article I try to do several things. First, I try to clarify the relevant objects of historical research in the field of education; in particular, I try to clarify cultural “transfer”, “transmission”, and “transformation” so as clarify the nature of the historical task to be undertaken. Second, I discuss the nature of historical “facts” and of historical research, in order to disabuse historians of both overly “empiricist” understandings of the historical record and overly “relativistic” understandings of historiography and the possibilities of genuine historical knowledge. Third, I address some key normative issues concerning the virtues and vices of both the educationally-caused transmission of culture and the educationally-caused transformation of it. Throughout the discussion, I try to illustrate the ways in which philosophical reflection can deepen our conception of the historical study of the relationship between education and culture.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)25-46
Number of pages22
JournalPaedagogica Historica
Volume32
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 1996

Fingerprint

historian
education
interaction
historiography
Historian
Education
Cultural Transmission
Causal
cause
Interaction
Historical Research

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education
  • History

Cite this

Education and cultural transmission/transformation. philosophical reflections on the historian's task. / Siegel, Harvey.

In: Paedagogica Historica, Vol. 32, 01.01.1996, p. 25-46.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{e26edc53eeac426eb5a8d4ecaff28942,
title = "Education and cultural transmission/transformation. philosophical reflections on the historian's task",
abstract = "Education seems obviously to be a cause of the transmission—and sometimes, of the transformation—of culture. Understanding this causal interaction is difficult, in part because “education” and “culture” are notoriously difficult to characterize with precision; and in part because the causal interaction goes in both directions: Culture has a causal impact on education that is apparently as great as, or perhaps even greater than, the causal impact of education on culture. How can we best understand the nature of this complex causal interaction? In this article I try to do several things. First, I try to clarify the relevant objects of historical research in the field of education; in particular, I try to clarify cultural “transfer”, “transmission”, and “transformation” so as clarify the nature of the historical task to be undertaken. Second, I discuss the nature of historical “facts” and of historical research, in order to disabuse historians of both overly “empiricist” understandings of the historical record and overly “relativistic” understandings of historiography and the possibilities of genuine historical knowledge. Third, I address some key normative issues concerning the virtues and vices of both the educationally-caused transmission of culture and the educationally-caused transformation of it. Throughout the discussion, I try to illustrate the ways in which philosophical reflection can deepen our conception of the historical study of the relationship between education and culture.",
author = "Harvey Siegel",
year = "1996",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1080/00309230.1996.11434856",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "32",
pages = "25--46",
journal = "Paedagogica Historica",
issn = "0030-9230",
publisher = "Routledge",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Education and cultural transmission/transformation. philosophical reflections on the historian's task

AU - Siegel, Harvey

PY - 1996/1/1

Y1 - 1996/1/1

N2 - Education seems obviously to be a cause of the transmission—and sometimes, of the transformation—of culture. Understanding this causal interaction is difficult, in part because “education” and “culture” are notoriously difficult to characterize with precision; and in part because the causal interaction goes in both directions: Culture has a causal impact on education that is apparently as great as, or perhaps even greater than, the causal impact of education on culture. How can we best understand the nature of this complex causal interaction? In this article I try to do several things. First, I try to clarify the relevant objects of historical research in the field of education; in particular, I try to clarify cultural “transfer”, “transmission”, and “transformation” so as clarify the nature of the historical task to be undertaken. Second, I discuss the nature of historical “facts” and of historical research, in order to disabuse historians of both overly “empiricist” understandings of the historical record and overly “relativistic” understandings of historiography and the possibilities of genuine historical knowledge. Third, I address some key normative issues concerning the virtues and vices of both the educationally-caused transmission of culture and the educationally-caused transformation of it. Throughout the discussion, I try to illustrate the ways in which philosophical reflection can deepen our conception of the historical study of the relationship between education and culture.

AB - Education seems obviously to be a cause of the transmission—and sometimes, of the transformation—of culture. Understanding this causal interaction is difficult, in part because “education” and “culture” are notoriously difficult to characterize with precision; and in part because the causal interaction goes in both directions: Culture has a causal impact on education that is apparently as great as, or perhaps even greater than, the causal impact of education on culture. How can we best understand the nature of this complex causal interaction? In this article I try to do several things. First, I try to clarify the relevant objects of historical research in the field of education; in particular, I try to clarify cultural “transfer”, “transmission”, and “transformation” so as clarify the nature of the historical task to be undertaken. Second, I discuss the nature of historical “facts” and of historical research, in order to disabuse historians of both overly “empiricist” understandings of the historical record and overly “relativistic” understandings of historiography and the possibilities of genuine historical knowledge. Third, I address some key normative issues concerning the virtues and vices of both the educationally-caused transmission of culture and the educationally-caused transformation of it. Throughout the discussion, I try to illustrate the ways in which philosophical reflection can deepen our conception of the historical study of the relationship between education and culture.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=79954716812&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=79954716812&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/00309230.1996.11434856

DO - 10.1080/00309230.1996.11434856

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:79954716812

VL - 32

SP - 25

EP - 46

JO - Paedagogica Historica

JF - Paedagogica Historica

SN - 0030-9230

ER -