Critique of the 2017 epileptic seizure and epilepsy classifications

Hans Lüders, Naoki Akamatsu, Shahram Amina, Christoph Baumgartner, Selim Benbadis, Adriana Bermeo-Ovalle, Andrew Bleasel, Alireza Bozorgi, Mar Carreño, Michael Devereaux, Guadalupe Fernandez-Baca Vaca, Stefano Francione, Naiara García Losarcos, Hajo Hamer, Hans Holthausen, Shirin Jamal Omidi, Giridhar Kalamangalam, Andres M Kanner, Susanne Knake, Nuria LacueySamden Lhatoo, Shih Hui Lim, Jayanthi Mani, Riki Matsumoto, Jonathan Miller, Soheyl Noachtar, André Palmini, Jun Park, Felix Rosenow, Asim Shahid, Stephan Schuele, Bernhard Steinhoff, Charles Ákos Szabo, Nitin Tandon, Kiyohito Terada, Walter Van Emde Boas, Peter Widdess-Walsh, Philippe Kahane

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This article critiques the International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) 2015-2017 classifications of epilepsy, epileptic seizures, and status epilepticus. It points out the following shortcomings of the ILAE classifications: (1) they mix semiological terms with epileptogenic zone terminology; (2) simple and widely accepted terminology has been replaced by complex terminology containing less information; (3) seizure evolution cannot be described in any detail; (4) in the four-level epilepsy classification, level two (epilepsy category) overlaps almost 100% with diagnostic level one (seizure type); and (5) the design of different classifications with distinct frameworks for newborns, adults, and patients in status epilepticus is confusing. The authors stress the importance of validating the new ILAE classifications and feel that the decision of Epilepsia to accept only manuscripts that use the ILAE classifications is premature and regrettable.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalEpilepsia
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

Epilepsy
Terminology
Status Epilepticus
Seizures
Manuscripts
Newborn Infant

Keywords

  • classification
  • epileptogenic zone
  • etiology
  • semiology

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Neurology
  • Clinical Neurology

Cite this

Lüders, H., Akamatsu, N., Amina, S., Baumgartner, C., Benbadis, S., Bermeo-Ovalle, A., ... Kahane, P. (2019). Critique of the 2017 epileptic seizure and epilepsy classifications. Epilepsia. https://doi.org/10.1111/epi.14699

Critique of the 2017 epileptic seizure and epilepsy classifications. / Lüders, Hans; Akamatsu, Naoki; Amina, Shahram; Baumgartner, Christoph; Benbadis, Selim; Bermeo-Ovalle, Adriana; Bleasel, Andrew; Bozorgi, Alireza; Carreño, Mar; Devereaux, Michael; Fernandez-Baca Vaca, Guadalupe; Francione, Stefano; García Losarcos, Naiara; Hamer, Hajo; Holthausen, Hans; Jamal Omidi, Shirin; Kalamangalam, Giridhar; Kanner, Andres M; Knake, Susanne; Lacuey, Nuria; Lhatoo, Samden; Lim, Shih Hui; Mani, Jayanthi; Matsumoto, Riki; Miller, Jonathan; Noachtar, Soheyl; Palmini, André; Park, Jun; Rosenow, Felix; Shahid, Asim; Schuele, Stephan; Steinhoff, Bernhard; Szabo, Charles Ákos; Tandon, Nitin; Terada, Kiyohito; Van Emde Boas, Walter; Widdess-Walsh, Peter; Kahane, Philippe.

In: Epilepsia, 01.01.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Lüders, H, Akamatsu, N, Amina, S, Baumgartner, C, Benbadis, S, Bermeo-Ovalle, A, Bleasel, A, Bozorgi, A, Carreño, M, Devereaux, M, Fernandez-Baca Vaca, G, Francione, S, García Losarcos, N, Hamer, H, Holthausen, H, Jamal Omidi, S, Kalamangalam, G, Kanner, AM, Knake, S, Lacuey, N, Lhatoo, S, Lim, SH, Mani, J, Matsumoto, R, Miller, J, Noachtar, S, Palmini, A, Park, J, Rosenow, F, Shahid, A, Schuele, S, Steinhoff, B, Szabo, CÁ, Tandon, N, Terada, K, Van Emde Boas, W, Widdess-Walsh, P & Kahane, P 2019, 'Critique of the 2017 epileptic seizure and epilepsy classifications', Epilepsia. https://doi.org/10.1111/epi.14699
Lüders H, Akamatsu N, Amina S, Baumgartner C, Benbadis S, Bermeo-Ovalle A et al. Critique of the 2017 epileptic seizure and epilepsy classifications. Epilepsia. 2019 Jan 1. https://doi.org/10.1111/epi.14699
Lüders, Hans ; Akamatsu, Naoki ; Amina, Shahram ; Baumgartner, Christoph ; Benbadis, Selim ; Bermeo-Ovalle, Adriana ; Bleasel, Andrew ; Bozorgi, Alireza ; Carreño, Mar ; Devereaux, Michael ; Fernandez-Baca Vaca, Guadalupe ; Francione, Stefano ; García Losarcos, Naiara ; Hamer, Hajo ; Holthausen, Hans ; Jamal Omidi, Shirin ; Kalamangalam, Giridhar ; Kanner, Andres M ; Knake, Susanne ; Lacuey, Nuria ; Lhatoo, Samden ; Lim, Shih Hui ; Mani, Jayanthi ; Matsumoto, Riki ; Miller, Jonathan ; Noachtar, Soheyl ; Palmini, André ; Park, Jun ; Rosenow, Felix ; Shahid, Asim ; Schuele, Stephan ; Steinhoff, Bernhard ; Szabo, Charles Ákos ; Tandon, Nitin ; Terada, Kiyohito ; Van Emde Boas, Walter ; Widdess-Walsh, Peter ; Kahane, Philippe. / Critique of the 2017 epileptic seizure and epilepsy classifications. In: Epilepsia. 2019.
@article{d5c5aa4363c3415ab88f3ad713c716bd,
title = "Critique of the 2017 epileptic seizure and epilepsy classifications",
abstract = "This article critiques the International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) 2015-2017 classifications of epilepsy, epileptic seizures, and status epilepticus. It points out the following shortcomings of the ILAE classifications: (1) they mix semiological terms with epileptogenic zone terminology; (2) simple and widely accepted terminology has been replaced by complex terminology containing less information; (3) seizure evolution cannot be described in any detail; (4) in the four-level epilepsy classification, level two (epilepsy category) overlaps almost 100{\%} with diagnostic level one (seizure type); and (5) the design of different classifications with distinct frameworks for newborns, adults, and patients in status epilepticus is confusing. The authors stress the importance of validating the new ILAE classifications and feel that the decision of Epilepsia to accept only manuscripts that use the ILAE classifications is premature and regrettable.",
keywords = "classification, epileptogenic zone, etiology, semiology",
author = "Hans L{\"u}ders and Naoki Akamatsu and Shahram Amina and Christoph Baumgartner and Selim Benbadis and Adriana Bermeo-Ovalle and Andrew Bleasel and Alireza Bozorgi and Mar Carre{\~n}o and Michael Devereaux and {Fernandez-Baca Vaca}, Guadalupe and Stefano Francione and {Garc{\'i}a Losarcos}, Naiara and Hajo Hamer and Hans Holthausen and {Jamal Omidi}, Shirin and Giridhar Kalamangalam and Kanner, {Andres M} and Susanne Knake and Nuria Lacuey and Samden Lhatoo and Lim, {Shih Hui} and Jayanthi Mani and Riki Matsumoto and Jonathan Miller and Soheyl Noachtar and Andr{\'e} Palmini and Jun Park and Felix Rosenow and Asim Shahid and Stephan Schuele and Bernhard Steinhoff and Szabo, {Charles {\'A}kos} and Nitin Tandon and Kiyohito Terada and {Van Emde Boas}, Walter and Peter Widdess-Walsh and Philippe Kahane",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/epi.14699",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Epilepsia",
issn = "0013-9580",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Critique of the 2017 epileptic seizure and epilepsy classifications

AU - Lüders, Hans

AU - Akamatsu, Naoki

AU - Amina, Shahram

AU - Baumgartner, Christoph

AU - Benbadis, Selim

AU - Bermeo-Ovalle, Adriana

AU - Bleasel, Andrew

AU - Bozorgi, Alireza

AU - Carreño, Mar

AU - Devereaux, Michael

AU - Fernandez-Baca Vaca, Guadalupe

AU - Francione, Stefano

AU - García Losarcos, Naiara

AU - Hamer, Hajo

AU - Holthausen, Hans

AU - Jamal Omidi, Shirin

AU - Kalamangalam, Giridhar

AU - Kanner, Andres M

AU - Knake, Susanne

AU - Lacuey, Nuria

AU - Lhatoo, Samden

AU - Lim, Shih Hui

AU - Mani, Jayanthi

AU - Matsumoto, Riki

AU - Miller, Jonathan

AU - Noachtar, Soheyl

AU - Palmini, André

AU - Park, Jun

AU - Rosenow, Felix

AU - Shahid, Asim

AU - Schuele, Stephan

AU - Steinhoff, Bernhard

AU - Szabo, Charles Ákos

AU - Tandon, Nitin

AU - Terada, Kiyohito

AU - Van Emde Boas, Walter

AU - Widdess-Walsh, Peter

AU - Kahane, Philippe

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - This article critiques the International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) 2015-2017 classifications of epilepsy, epileptic seizures, and status epilepticus. It points out the following shortcomings of the ILAE classifications: (1) they mix semiological terms with epileptogenic zone terminology; (2) simple and widely accepted terminology has been replaced by complex terminology containing less information; (3) seizure evolution cannot be described in any detail; (4) in the four-level epilepsy classification, level two (epilepsy category) overlaps almost 100% with diagnostic level one (seizure type); and (5) the design of different classifications with distinct frameworks for newborns, adults, and patients in status epilepticus is confusing. The authors stress the importance of validating the new ILAE classifications and feel that the decision of Epilepsia to accept only manuscripts that use the ILAE classifications is premature and regrettable.

AB - This article critiques the International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) 2015-2017 classifications of epilepsy, epileptic seizures, and status epilepticus. It points out the following shortcomings of the ILAE classifications: (1) they mix semiological terms with epileptogenic zone terminology; (2) simple and widely accepted terminology has been replaced by complex terminology containing less information; (3) seizure evolution cannot be described in any detail; (4) in the four-level epilepsy classification, level two (epilepsy category) overlaps almost 100% with diagnostic level one (seizure type); and (5) the design of different classifications with distinct frameworks for newborns, adults, and patients in status epilepticus is confusing. The authors stress the importance of validating the new ILAE classifications and feel that the decision of Epilepsia to accept only manuscripts that use the ILAE classifications is premature and regrettable.

KW - classification

KW - epileptogenic zone

KW - etiology

KW - semiology

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85063632994&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85063632994&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/epi.14699

DO - 10.1111/epi.14699

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85063632994

JO - Epilepsia

JF - Epilepsia

SN - 0013-9580

ER -