Biomechanics of ulnar osteotomies and plate fixation

John M. Rayhack, Seth I. Gasser, Edward L. Milne, Loren L. Latta

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

Osteotomies to shorten the ulna have proven to be an effective procedure for ulnar positive wrist syndrome. However, the procedure has been fraught with a number of mechanical problems which have limited its clinical and biological success. This work proposes a solution for some of these mechanical problems and tests this hypothesis in the laboratory and the clinical setting. Twenty pairs of human ulnas (5 pairs in each group) had shortening osteotomies performed. One side had conventional transverse, 'free-hand' cuts, coaptation by hand and compression and neutralization by a standard AO 3.5 mm, 7-hole DCP Plate. The contralateral ulna had a fixture attached to the bone to control the cutting saw and the bone fragments throughout the 45° osteotomy cuts and controlled coaptation and compression with an intrafragmentary lag screw and neutralization with a 2.5 mm, low profile, 7-hole plate. After the co-aptation, compression and neutralization were complete, the fixture was removed, and each ulna was elastically tested for bending (in two planes) and torsion stiffness, and for strength in apex volar bending. Bending stiffness of both plate designs was also measured. Structural stiffness was clearly greater in torsion testing for the oblique osteotomy at a significance level of P > .04. No biomechanical difference was identified in the AP and lateral bending tests despite the fact that the low profile plate was only half the bending rigidity of the standard plate. In a clinical trial, twenty-three transverse osteotomies were compared to seventeen oblique osteotomies using the described instruments. The healing rate and consistency was improved for the oblique osteotomy group compared to the transverse osteotomy group by 10.9 versus 20.6 weeks to healing in 100% versus 96% completely healed cases, respectively. The osteotomy instrumentation system not only provided the surgeon with a means of reducing operative time, post-operative complications, ease of implementation and reduced hardware bulk in the subcutaneous region, but also improved the mechanical and clinical performance for short and long term due to the precision and configuration of the construct, requiring less mechanically demanding hardware.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Title of host publicationASTM Special Technical Publication
PublisherPubl by ASTM
Pages103-109
Number of pages7
Edition1217
StatePublished - 1994
EventProceedings of the Conference on Clinical and Laboratory Performance of Bone Plates - Atlanta, GA, USA
Duration: May 5 1993May 5 1993

Other

OtherProceedings of the Conference on Clinical and Laboratory Performance of Bone Plates
CityAtlanta, GA, USA
Period5/5/935/5/93

Fingerprint

Biomechanics
Bending (deformation)
Stiffness
Bone
Torsion testing
Hardware
Bending tests
Rigidity
Torsional stress

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Engineering(all)

Cite this

Rayhack, J. M., Gasser, S. I., Milne, E. L., & Latta, L. L. (1994). Biomechanics of ulnar osteotomies and plate fixation. In ASTM Special Technical Publication (1217 ed., pp. 103-109). Publ by ASTM.

Biomechanics of ulnar osteotomies and plate fixation. / Rayhack, John M.; Gasser, Seth I.; Milne, Edward L.; Latta, Loren L.

ASTM Special Technical Publication. 1217. ed. Publ by ASTM, 1994. p. 103-109.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Rayhack, JM, Gasser, SI, Milne, EL & Latta, LL 1994, Biomechanics of ulnar osteotomies and plate fixation. in ASTM Special Technical Publication. 1217 edn, Publ by ASTM, pp. 103-109, Proceedings of the Conference on Clinical and Laboratory Performance of Bone Plates, Atlanta, GA, USA, 5/5/93.
Rayhack JM, Gasser SI, Milne EL, Latta LL. Biomechanics of ulnar osteotomies and plate fixation. In ASTM Special Technical Publication. 1217 ed. Publ by ASTM. 1994. p. 103-109
Rayhack, John M. ; Gasser, Seth I. ; Milne, Edward L. ; Latta, Loren L. / Biomechanics of ulnar osteotomies and plate fixation. ASTM Special Technical Publication. 1217. ed. Publ by ASTM, 1994. pp. 103-109
@inproceedings{6941e812355c4e8ea30c3cca104d1f9c,
title = "Biomechanics of ulnar osteotomies and plate fixation",
abstract = "Osteotomies to shorten the ulna have proven to be an effective procedure for ulnar positive wrist syndrome. However, the procedure has been fraught with a number of mechanical problems which have limited its clinical and biological success. This work proposes a solution for some of these mechanical problems and tests this hypothesis in the laboratory and the clinical setting. Twenty pairs of human ulnas (5 pairs in each group) had shortening osteotomies performed. One side had conventional transverse, 'free-hand' cuts, coaptation by hand and compression and neutralization by a standard AO 3.5 mm, 7-hole DCP Plate. The contralateral ulna had a fixture attached to the bone to control the cutting saw and the bone fragments throughout the 45° osteotomy cuts and controlled coaptation and compression with an intrafragmentary lag screw and neutralization with a 2.5 mm, low profile, 7-hole plate. After the co-aptation, compression and neutralization were complete, the fixture was removed, and each ulna was elastically tested for bending (in two planes) and torsion stiffness, and for strength in apex volar bending. Bending stiffness of both plate designs was also measured. Structural stiffness was clearly greater in torsion testing for the oblique osteotomy at a significance level of P > .04. No biomechanical difference was identified in the AP and lateral bending tests despite the fact that the low profile plate was only half the bending rigidity of the standard plate. In a clinical trial, twenty-three transverse osteotomies were compared to seventeen oblique osteotomies using the described instruments. The healing rate and consistency was improved for the oblique osteotomy group compared to the transverse osteotomy group by 10.9 versus 20.6 weeks to healing in 100{\%} versus 96{\%} completely healed cases, respectively. The osteotomy instrumentation system not only provided the surgeon with a means of reducing operative time, post-operative complications, ease of implementation and reduced hardware bulk in the subcutaneous region, but also improved the mechanical and clinical performance for short and long term due to the precision and configuration of the construct, requiring less mechanically demanding hardware.",
author = "Rayhack, {John M.} and Gasser, {Seth I.} and Milne, {Edward L.} and Latta, {Loren L.}",
year = "1994",
language = "English (US)",
pages = "103--109",
booktitle = "ASTM Special Technical Publication",
publisher = "Publ by ASTM",
edition = "1217",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - Biomechanics of ulnar osteotomies and plate fixation

AU - Rayhack, John M.

AU - Gasser, Seth I.

AU - Milne, Edward L.

AU - Latta, Loren L.

PY - 1994

Y1 - 1994

N2 - Osteotomies to shorten the ulna have proven to be an effective procedure for ulnar positive wrist syndrome. However, the procedure has been fraught with a number of mechanical problems which have limited its clinical and biological success. This work proposes a solution for some of these mechanical problems and tests this hypothesis in the laboratory and the clinical setting. Twenty pairs of human ulnas (5 pairs in each group) had shortening osteotomies performed. One side had conventional transverse, 'free-hand' cuts, coaptation by hand and compression and neutralization by a standard AO 3.5 mm, 7-hole DCP Plate. The contralateral ulna had a fixture attached to the bone to control the cutting saw and the bone fragments throughout the 45° osteotomy cuts and controlled coaptation and compression with an intrafragmentary lag screw and neutralization with a 2.5 mm, low profile, 7-hole plate. After the co-aptation, compression and neutralization were complete, the fixture was removed, and each ulna was elastically tested for bending (in two planes) and torsion stiffness, and for strength in apex volar bending. Bending stiffness of both plate designs was also measured. Structural stiffness was clearly greater in torsion testing for the oblique osteotomy at a significance level of P > .04. No biomechanical difference was identified in the AP and lateral bending tests despite the fact that the low profile plate was only half the bending rigidity of the standard plate. In a clinical trial, twenty-three transverse osteotomies were compared to seventeen oblique osteotomies using the described instruments. The healing rate and consistency was improved for the oblique osteotomy group compared to the transverse osteotomy group by 10.9 versus 20.6 weeks to healing in 100% versus 96% completely healed cases, respectively. The osteotomy instrumentation system not only provided the surgeon with a means of reducing operative time, post-operative complications, ease of implementation and reduced hardware bulk in the subcutaneous region, but also improved the mechanical and clinical performance for short and long term due to the precision and configuration of the construct, requiring less mechanically demanding hardware.

AB - Osteotomies to shorten the ulna have proven to be an effective procedure for ulnar positive wrist syndrome. However, the procedure has been fraught with a number of mechanical problems which have limited its clinical and biological success. This work proposes a solution for some of these mechanical problems and tests this hypothesis in the laboratory and the clinical setting. Twenty pairs of human ulnas (5 pairs in each group) had shortening osteotomies performed. One side had conventional transverse, 'free-hand' cuts, coaptation by hand and compression and neutralization by a standard AO 3.5 mm, 7-hole DCP Plate. The contralateral ulna had a fixture attached to the bone to control the cutting saw and the bone fragments throughout the 45° osteotomy cuts and controlled coaptation and compression with an intrafragmentary lag screw and neutralization with a 2.5 mm, low profile, 7-hole plate. After the co-aptation, compression and neutralization were complete, the fixture was removed, and each ulna was elastically tested for bending (in two planes) and torsion stiffness, and for strength in apex volar bending. Bending stiffness of both plate designs was also measured. Structural stiffness was clearly greater in torsion testing for the oblique osteotomy at a significance level of P > .04. No biomechanical difference was identified in the AP and lateral bending tests despite the fact that the low profile plate was only half the bending rigidity of the standard plate. In a clinical trial, twenty-three transverse osteotomies were compared to seventeen oblique osteotomies using the described instruments. The healing rate and consistency was improved for the oblique osteotomy group compared to the transverse osteotomy group by 10.9 versus 20.6 weeks to healing in 100% versus 96% completely healed cases, respectively. The osteotomy instrumentation system not only provided the surgeon with a means of reducing operative time, post-operative complications, ease of implementation and reduced hardware bulk in the subcutaneous region, but also improved the mechanical and clinical performance for short and long term due to the precision and configuration of the construct, requiring less mechanically demanding hardware.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0028262030&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0028262030&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Conference contribution

SP - 103

EP - 109

BT - ASTM Special Technical Publication

PB - Publ by ASTM

ER -