An indicator-based adaptive management framework and its development for data-limited fisheries in Belize

Gavin McDonald, Bill Harford, Alejandro Arrivillaga, Elizabeth A Babcock, Ramon Carcamo, James Foley, Rod Fujita, Todd Gedamke, Janet Gibson, Kendra Karr, Julie Robinson, Jono Wilson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

14 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Decisions regarding the selection and implementation of management strategies that constrain fishing pressure can be among the most difficult choices that fisheries managers and stakeholders must make. These types of decisions often need to be confronted in a data-limited context, where few if any management measures are currently in place or fisheries are managed independent of adequate scientific advice. This situation can sometimes create a high risk of overfishing and potential loss of economic and social benefits. To address this situation, simple model-free indicator-based frameworks have the potential to be effective decision-making platforms for fisheries where quantitative estimates of biomass and fishing mortality based reference points are lacking. In this paper, a multi-indicator framework is developed that enables decision-makers to proceed with management decisions in data-limited situations. Model-free indicators are calculated using trends in observed data, rather than stock assessment derived estimates of biomass and fishing mortality. The framework developed is adaptive so that adjustments to catch or effort are recursive and can respond to changing environments, socioeconomic conditions, and fishing practices. Using stakeholder-defined objectives as a foundation, indicators and reference points of fishery performance are chosen that can be evaluated easily by undertaking analyses of available data. Indicators from multiple data streams are used so that uncertainty in one indicator can be hedged through careful interpretation and corroboration of information from alternative indicators. During the adaptive management cycle, managers and stakeholders evaluate each indicator against the associated reference points to determine performance measures, interpret the results using scientific and local knowledge, and adjust fishery management tactics accordingly using pre-defined harvest control rules. The framework facilitates the interpretation of situations in which performance measures suggest divergent stock abundance or productivity levels. A case study is presented on this framework's development for conch and lobster fisheries of Belize.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)28-37
Number of pages10
JournalMarine Policy
Volume76
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 1 2017

Fingerprint

Belize
adaptive management
fishery
fisheries
stakeholders
management
managers
lobster fisheries
stakeholder
social benefit
fishing mortality
overfishing
biomass
fisheries management
socioeconomics
decision making
fishing
uncertainty
mortality
lobster fishery

Keywords

  • Adaptive management
  • Data-limited fisheries
  • Decision-support frameworks
  • Model-free indicators

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Aquatic Science
  • Environmental Science(all)
  • Economics and Econometrics
  • Management, Monitoring, Policy and Law
  • Law

Cite this

An indicator-based adaptive management framework and its development for data-limited fisheries in Belize. / McDonald, Gavin; Harford, Bill; Arrivillaga, Alejandro; Babcock, Elizabeth A; Carcamo, Ramon; Foley, James; Fujita, Rod; Gedamke, Todd; Gibson, Janet; Karr, Kendra; Robinson, Julie; Wilson, Jono.

In: Marine Policy, Vol. 76, 01.02.2017, p. 28-37.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

McDonald, G, Harford, B, Arrivillaga, A, Babcock, EA, Carcamo, R, Foley, J, Fujita, R, Gedamke, T, Gibson, J, Karr, K, Robinson, J & Wilson, J 2017, 'An indicator-based adaptive management framework and its development for data-limited fisheries in Belize', Marine Policy, vol. 76, pp. 28-37. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2016.11.027
McDonald, Gavin ; Harford, Bill ; Arrivillaga, Alejandro ; Babcock, Elizabeth A ; Carcamo, Ramon ; Foley, James ; Fujita, Rod ; Gedamke, Todd ; Gibson, Janet ; Karr, Kendra ; Robinson, Julie ; Wilson, Jono. / An indicator-based adaptive management framework and its development for data-limited fisheries in Belize. In: Marine Policy. 2017 ; Vol. 76. pp. 28-37.
@article{624a5a9d745047ddb6f03888097e7a07,
title = "An indicator-based adaptive management framework and its development for data-limited fisheries in Belize",
abstract = "Decisions regarding the selection and implementation of management strategies that constrain fishing pressure can be among the most difficult choices that fisheries managers and stakeholders must make. These types of decisions often need to be confronted in a data-limited context, where few if any management measures are currently in place or fisheries are managed independent of adequate scientific advice. This situation can sometimes create a high risk of overfishing and potential loss of economic and social benefits. To address this situation, simple model-free indicator-based frameworks have the potential to be effective decision-making platforms for fisheries where quantitative estimates of biomass and fishing mortality based reference points are lacking. In this paper, a multi-indicator framework is developed that enables decision-makers to proceed with management decisions in data-limited situations. Model-free indicators are calculated using trends in observed data, rather than stock assessment derived estimates of biomass and fishing mortality. The framework developed is adaptive so that adjustments to catch or effort are recursive and can respond to changing environments, socioeconomic conditions, and fishing practices. Using stakeholder-defined objectives as a foundation, indicators and reference points of fishery performance are chosen that can be evaluated easily by undertaking analyses of available data. Indicators from multiple data streams are used so that uncertainty in one indicator can be hedged through careful interpretation and corroboration of information from alternative indicators. During the adaptive management cycle, managers and stakeholders evaluate each indicator against the associated reference points to determine performance measures, interpret the results using scientific and local knowledge, and adjust fishery management tactics accordingly using pre-defined harvest control rules. The framework facilitates the interpretation of situations in which performance measures suggest divergent stock abundance or productivity levels. A case study is presented on this framework's development for conch and lobster fisheries of Belize.",
keywords = "Adaptive management, Data-limited fisheries, Decision-support frameworks, Model-free indicators",
author = "Gavin McDonald and Bill Harford and Alejandro Arrivillaga and Babcock, {Elizabeth A} and Ramon Carcamo and James Foley and Rod Fujita and Todd Gedamke and Janet Gibson and Kendra Karr and Julie Robinson and Jono Wilson",
year = "2017",
month = "2",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.marpol.2016.11.027",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "76",
pages = "28--37",
journal = "Marine Policy",
issn = "0308-597X",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - An indicator-based adaptive management framework and its development for data-limited fisheries in Belize

AU - McDonald, Gavin

AU - Harford, Bill

AU - Arrivillaga, Alejandro

AU - Babcock, Elizabeth A

AU - Carcamo, Ramon

AU - Foley, James

AU - Fujita, Rod

AU - Gedamke, Todd

AU - Gibson, Janet

AU - Karr, Kendra

AU - Robinson, Julie

AU - Wilson, Jono

PY - 2017/2/1

Y1 - 2017/2/1

N2 - Decisions regarding the selection and implementation of management strategies that constrain fishing pressure can be among the most difficult choices that fisheries managers and stakeholders must make. These types of decisions often need to be confronted in a data-limited context, where few if any management measures are currently in place or fisheries are managed independent of adequate scientific advice. This situation can sometimes create a high risk of overfishing and potential loss of economic and social benefits. To address this situation, simple model-free indicator-based frameworks have the potential to be effective decision-making platforms for fisheries where quantitative estimates of biomass and fishing mortality based reference points are lacking. In this paper, a multi-indicator framework is developed that enables decision-makers to proceed with management decisions in data-limited situations. Model-free indicators are calculated using trends in observed data, rather than stock assessment derived estimates of biomass and fishing mortality. The framework developed is adaptive so that adjustments to catch or effort are recursive and can respond to changing environments, socioeconomic conditions, and fishing practices. Using stakeholder-defined objectives as a foundation, indicators and reference points of fishery performance are chosen that can be evaluated easily by undertaking analyses of available data. Indicators from multiple data streams are used so that uncertainty in one indicator can be hedged through careful interpretation and corroboration of information from alternative indicators. During the adaptive management cycle, managers and stakeholders evaluate each indicator against the associated reference points to determine performance measures, interpret the results using scientific and local knowledge, and adjust fishery management tactics accordingly using pre-defined harvest control rules. The framework facilitates the interpretation of situations in which performance measures suggest divergent stock abundance or productivity levels. A case study is presented on this framework's development for conch and lobster fisheries of Belize.

AB - Decisions regarding the selection and implementation of management strategies that constrain fishing pressure can be among the most difficult choices that fisheries managers and stakeholders must make. These types of decisions often need to be confronted in a data-limited context, where few if any management measures are currently in place or fisheries are managed independent of adequate scientific advice. This situation can sometimes create a high risk of overfishing and potential loss of economic and social benefits. To address this situation, simple model-free indicator-based frameworks have the potential to be effective decision-making platforms for fisheries where quantitative estimates of biomass and fishing mortality based reference points are lacking. In this paper, a multi-indicator framework is developed that enables decision-makers to proceed with management decisions in data-limited situations. Model-free indicators are calculated using trends in observed data, rather than stock assessment derived estimates of biomass and fishing mortality. The framework developed is adaptive so that adjustments to catch or effort are recursive and can respond to changing environments, socioeconomic conditions, and fishing practices. Using stakeholder-defined objectives as a foundation, indicators and reference points of fishery performance are chosen that can be evaluated easily by undertaking analyses of available data. Indicators from multiple data streams are used so that uncertainty in one indicator can be hedged through careful interpretation and corroboration of information from alternative indicators. During the adaptive management cycle, managers and stakeholders evaluate each indicator against the associated reference points to determine performance measures, interpret the results using scientific and local knowledge, and adjust fishery management tactics accordingly using pre-defined harvest control rules. The framework facilitates the interpretation of situations in which performance measures suggest divergent stock abundance or productivity levels. A case study is presented on this framework's development for conch and lobster fisheries of Belize.

KW - Adaptive management

KW - Data-limited fisheries

KW - Decision-support frameworks

KW - Model-free indicators

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84996773896&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84996773896&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.marpol.2016.11.027

DO - 10.1016/j.marpol.2016.11.027

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84996773896

VL - 76

SP - 28

EP - 37

JO - Marine Policy

JF - Marine Policy

SN - 0308-597X

ER -