An evaluation of management strategies for Atlantic tuna stocks

L. T. Kell, David J Die, V. R. Restrepo, J. M. Fromentin, V. Ortiz De Zarate, P. Pallares

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

17 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

International agreements for the International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (ICCAT) convention area imply that Atlantic tuna stocks should be managed by strategies based on maximum sustainable yield (MSY); however, there is concern whether this will actually ensure sustainability with sufficiently high probability consistent with the principals of the precautionary approach. Therefore, the performance of MSY management strategies based on current assessment procedures was evaluated using a computer simulation framework. The framework includes the data collection, assessment, prediction, and management processes, as well as the implementation of management regulations. It therefore provides an integrated way to evaluate the relative importance of and the interactions between each component of the system with regard to the overall success of the management strategy. The study elucidates guidelines about assessment and management that are general enough to be applied to all tunas in the Atlantic Ocean. It does so by comparing different hypotheses about management and assessment for three stocks (North Atlantic albacore. Atlantic bigeye and East Atlantic skipjack), which are representative of the variety encountered (i.e. from data rich to poor and tropical to temperate waters) in ICCAT stocks. Management performance was especially sensitive to the carrying capacity of the stock. The type of proxy used for MSY was more important to the success of the procedure than the frequency of assessment or the number of indices used in the assessment. Whilst the procedure was successful at achieving the management objectives for albacore, it was only partially successful for bigeye and was too conservative for skipjack.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)353-370
Number of pages18
JournalScientia Marina
Volume67
Issue numberSUPPL 1
StatePublished - Apr 1 2003

Fingerprint

tuna
maximum sustainable yield
Thunnus alalunga
international agreements
international agreement
carrying capacity
evaluation
computer simulation
Atlantic Ocean
sustainability
prediction
ocean

Keywords

  • Albacore
  • Bigeye
  • Evaluation
  • ICCAT
  • Management
  • Simulation
  • Skipjack
  • Strategy

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Aquatic Science

Cite this

Kell, L. T., Die, D. J., Restrepo, V. R., Fromentin, J. M., De Zarate, V. O., & Pallares, P. (2003). An evaluation of management strategies for Atlantic tuna stocks. Scientia Marina, 67(SUPPL 1), 353-370.

An evaluation of management strategies for Atlantic tuna stocks. / Kell, L. T.; Die, David J; Restrepo, V. R.; Fromentin, J. M.; De Zarate, V. Ortiz; Pallares, P.

In: Scientia Marina, Vol. 67, No. SUPPL 1, 01.04.2003, p. 353-370.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Kell, LT, Die, DJ, Restrepo, VR, Fromentin, JM, De Zarate, VO & Pallares, P 2003, 'An evaluation of management strategies for Atlantic tuna stocks', Scientia Marina, vol. 67, no. SUPPL 1, pp. 353-370.
Kell LT, Die DJ, Restrepo VR, Fromentin JM, De Zarate VO, Pallares P. An evaluation of management strategies for Atlantic tuna stocks. Scientia Marina. 2003 Apr 1;67(SUPPL 1):353-370.
Kell, L. T. ; Die, David J ; Restrepo, V. R. ; Fromentin, J. M. ; De Zarate, V. Ortiz ; Pallares, P. / An evaluation of management strategies for Atlantic tuna stocks. In: Scientia Marina. 2003 ; Vol. 67, No. SUPPL 1. pp. 353-370.
@article{b6476b28e57a4731a225b2477b738c48,
title = "An evaluation of management strategies for Atlantic tuna stocks",
abstract = "International agreements for the International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (ICCAT) convention area imply that Atlantic tuna stocks should be managed by strategies based on maximum sustainable yield (MSY); however, there is concern whether this will actually ensure sustainability with sufficiently high probability consistent with the principals of the precautionary approach. Therefore, the performance of MSY management strategies based on current assessment procedures was evaluated using a computer simulation framework. The framework includes the data collection, assessment, prediction, and management processes, as well as the implementation of management regulations. It therefore provides an integrated way to evaluate the relative importance of and the interactions between each component of the system with regard to the overall success of the management strategy. The study elucidates guidelines about assessment and management that are general enough to be applied to all tunas in the Atlantic Ocean. It does so by comparing different hypotheses about management and assessment for three stocks (North Atlantic albacore. Atlantic bigeye and East Atlantic skipjack), which are representative of the variety encountered (i.e. from data rich to poor and tropical to temperate waters) in ICCAT stocks. Management performance was especially sensitive to the carrying capacity of the stock. The type of proxy used for MSY was more important to the success of the procedure than the frequency of assessment or the number of indices used in the assessment. Whilst the procedure was successful at achieving the management objectives for albacore, it was only partially successful for bigeye and was too conservative for skipjack.",
keywords = "Albacore, Bigeye, Evaluation, ICCAT, Management, Simulation, Skipjack, Strategy",
author = "Kell, {L. T.} and Die, {David J} and Restrepo, {V. R.} and Fromentin, {J. M.} and {De Zarate}, {V. Ortiz} and P. Pallares",
year = "2003",
month = "4",
day = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "67",
pages = "353--370",
journal = "Scientia Marina",
issn = "0214-8358",
publisher = "CSIC Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Cientificas",
number = "SUPPL 1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - An evaluation of management strategies for Atlantic tuna stocks

AU - Kell, L. T.

AU - Die, David J

AU - Restrepo, V. R.

AU - Fromentin, J. M.

AU - De Zarate, V. Ortiz

AU - Pallares, P.

PY - 2003/4/1

Y1 - 2003/4/1

N2 - International agreements for the International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (ICCAT) convention area imply that Atlantic tuna stocks should be managed by strategies based on maximum sustainable yield (MSY); however, there is concern whether this will actually ensure sustainability with sufficiently high probability consistent with the principals of the precautionary approach. Therefore, the performance of MSY management strategies based on current assessment procedures was evaluated using a computer simulation framework. The framework includes the data collection, assessment, prediction, and management processes, as well as the implementation of management regulations. It therefore provides an integrated way to evaluate the relative importance of and the interactions between each component of the system with regard to the overall success of the management strategy. The study elucidates guidelines about assessment and management that are general enough to be applied to all tunas in the Atlantic Ocean. It does so by comparing different hypotheses about management and assessment for three stocks (North Atlantic albacore. Atlantic bigeye and East Atlantic skipjack), which are representative of the variety encountered (i.e. from data rich to poor and tropical to temperate waters) in ICCAT stocks. Management performance was especially sensitive to the carrying capacity of the stock. The type of proxy used for MSY was more important to the success of the procedure than the frequency of assessment or the number of indices used in the assessment. Whilst the procedure was successful at achieving the management objectives for albacore, it was only partially successful for bigeye and was too conservative for skipjack.

AB - International agreements for the International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (ICCAT) convention area imply that Atlantic tuna stocks should be managed by strategies based on maximum sustainable yield (MSY); however, there is concern whether this will actually ensure sustainability with sufficiently high probability consistent with the principals of the precautionary approach. Therefore, the performance of MSY management strategies based on current assessment procedures was evaluated using a computer simulation framework. The framework includes the data collection, assessment, prediction, and management processes, as well as the implementation of management regulations. It therefore provides an integrated way to evaluate the relative importance of and the interactions between each component of the system with regard to the overall success of the management strategy. The study elucidates guidelines about assessment and management that are general enough to be applied to all tunas in the Atlantic Ocean. It does so by comparing different hypotheses about management and assessment for three stocks (North Atlantic albacore. Atlantic bigeye and East Atlantic skipjack), which are representative of the variety encountered (i.e. from data rich to poor and tropical to temperate waters) in ICCAT stocks. Management performance was especially sensitive to the carrying capacity of the stock. The type of proxy used for MSY was more important to the success of the procedure than the frequency of assessment or the number of indices used in the assessment. Whilst the procedure was successful at achieving the management objectives for albacore, it was only partially successful for bigeye and was too conservative for skipjack.

KW - Albacore

KW - Bigeye

KW - Evaluation

KW - ICCAT

KW - Management

KW - Simulation

KW - Skipjack

KW - Strategy

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0042126974&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0042126974&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 67

SP - 353

EP - 370

JO - Scientia Marina

JF - Scientia Marina

SN - 0214-8358

IS - SUPPL 1

ER -