Amphibian responses to livestock use of wetlands: new empirical data and a global review

Hunter J. Howell, Caitlin C. Mothes, Stephanie L. Clements, Shantel V. Catania, Betsie B. Rothermel, Christopher Searcy

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Pastureland currently occupies 26% of Earth's ice-free land surface. As the global human population continues to increase and developing countries consume more protein-rich diets, the amount of land devoted to livestock grazing will only continue to rise. To mitigate the loss of global biodiversity as a consequence of the ever-expanding amount of land converted from native habitat into pastureland for livestock grazing, an understanding of how livestock impact wildlife is critical. While previous reviews have examined the impact of livestock on a wide variety of taxa, there have been no reviews examining how global livestock grazing affects amphibians. We conducted both an empirical study in south-central Florida examining the impact of cattle on amphibian communities and a quantitative literature review of similar studies on five continents. Our empirical study analyzed amphibian community responses to cattle as both a binary (presence/absence) variable, and as a continuous variable based on cow pie density. Across all analyses, we were unable to find any evidence that cattle affected the amphibian community at our study site. The literature review returned 46 papers that met our criteria for inclusion. Of these studies, 15 found positive effects of livestock on amphibians, 21 found neutral/mixed effects, and 10 found negative effects. Our quantitative analysis of these data indicates that amphibian species that historically occurred in closed-canopy habitats are generally negatively affected by livestock presence. In contrast, open-canopy amphibians are likely to experience positive effects from the presence of livestock, and these positive effects are most likely to occur in locations with cooler climates and/or greater precipitation seasonality. Collectively, our empirical work and literature review demonstrate that under the correct conditions well-managed rangelands are able to support diverse assemblages of amphibians. These rangeland ecosystems may play a critical role in protecting future amphibian biodiversity by serving as an “off-reserve” system to supplement the biodiversity conserved within traditional protected areas.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article numbere01976
JournalEcological Applications
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

amphibian
livestock
wetland
literature review
cattle
grazing
biodiversity
rangeland
canopy
community response
habitat
quantitative analysis
seasonality
protected area
land surface
developing world
effect
diet
ice
protein

Keywords

  • Anura
  • cattle
  • Caudata
  • climate
  • community
  • conservation
  • land-use
  • rangeland

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology

Cite this

Howell, H. J., Mothes, C. C., Clements, S. L., Catania, S. V., Rothermel, B. B., & Searcy, C. (Accepted/In press). Amphibian responses to livestock use of wetlands: new empirical data and a global review. Ecological Applications, [e01976]. https://doi.org/10.1002/eap.1976

Amphibian responses to livestock use of wetlands : new empirical data and a global review. / Howell, Hunter J.; Mothes, Caitlin C.; Clements, Stephanie L.; Catania, Shantel V.; Rothermel, Betsie B.; Searcy, Christopher.

In: Ecological Applications, 01.01.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Howell, Hunter J. ; Mothes, Caitlin C. ; Clements, Stephanie L. ; Catania, Shantel V. ; Rothermel, Betsie B. ; Searcy, Christopher. / Amphibian responses to livestock use of wetlands : new empirical data and a global review. In: Ecological Applications. 2019.
@article{d087266b7e084cbe9d752459b76bbc2f,
title = "Amphibian responses to livestock use of wetlands: new empirical data and a global review",
abstract = "Pastureland currently occupies 26{\%} of Earth's ice-free land surface. As the global human population continues to increase and developing countries consume more protein-rich diets, the amount of land devoted to livestock grazing will only continue to rise. To mitigate the loss of global biodiversity as a consequence of the ever-expanding amount of land converted from native habitat into pastureland for livestock grazing, an understanding of how livestock impact wildlife is critical. While previous reviews have examined the impact of livestock on a wide variety of taxa, there have been no reviews examining how global livestock grazing affects amphibians. We conducted both an empirical study in south-central Florida examining the impact of cattle on amphibian communities and a quantitative literature review of similar studies on five continents. Our empirical study analyzed amphibian community responses to cattle as both a binary (presence/absence) variable, and as a continuous variable based on cow pie density. Across all analyses, we were unable to find any evidence that cattle affected the amphibian community at our study site. The literature review returned 46 papers that met our criteria for inclusion. Of these studies, 15 found positive effects of livestock on amphibians, 21 found neutral/mixed effects, and 10 found negative effects. Our quantitative analysis of these data indicates that amphibian species that historically occurred in closed-canopy habitats are generally negatively affected by livestock presence. In contrast, open-canopy amphibians are likely to experience positive effects from the presence of livestock, and these positive effects are most likely to occur in locations with cooler climates and/or greater precipitation seasonality. Collectively, our empirical work and literature review demonstrate that under the correct conditions well-managed rangelands are able to support diverse assemblages of amphibians. These rangeland ecosystems may play a critical role in protecting future amphibian biodiversity by serving as an “off-reserve” system to supplement the biodiversity conserved within traditional protected areas.",
keywords = "Anura, cattle, Caudata, climate, community, conservation, land-use, rangeland",
author = "Howell, {Hunter J.} and Mothes, {Caitlin C.} and Clements, {Stephanie L.} and Catania, {Shantel V.} and Rothermel, {Betsie B.} and Christopher Searcy",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/eap.1976",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Ecological Appplications",
issn = "1051-0761",
publisher = "Ecological Society of America",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Amphibian responses to livestock use of wetlands

T2 - new empirical data and a global review

AU - Howell, Hunter J.

AU - Mothes, Caitlin C.

AU - Clements, Stephanie L.

AU - Catania, Shantel V.

AU - Rothermel, Betsie B.

AU - Searcy, Christopher

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Pastureland currently occupies 26% of Earth's ice-free land surface. As the global human population continues to increase and developing countries consume more protein-rich diets, the amount of land devoted to livestock grazing will only continue to rise. To mitigate the loss of global biodiversity as a consequence of the ever-expanding amount of land converted from native habitat into pastureland for livestock grazing, an understanding of how livestock impact wildlife is critical. While previous reviews have examined the impact of livestock on a wide variety of taxa, there have been no reviews examining how global livestock grazing affects amphibians. We conducted both an empirical study in south-central Florida examining the impact of cattle on amphibian communities and a quantitative literature review of similar studies on five continents. Our empirical study analyzed amphibian community responses to cattle as both a binary (presence/absence) variable, and as a continuous variable based on cow pie density. Across all analyses, we were unable to find any evidence that cattle affected the amphibian community at our study site. The literature review returned 46 papers that met our criteria for inclusion. Of these studies, 15 found positive effects of livestock on amphibians, 21 found neutral/mixed effects, and 10 found negative effects. Our quantitative analysis of these data indicates that amphibian species that historically occurred in closed-canopy habitats are generally negatively affected by livestock presence. In contrast, open-canopy amphibians are likely to experience positive effects from the presence of livestock, and these positive effects are most likely to occur in locations with cooler climates and/or greater precipitation seasonality. Collectively, our empirical work and literature review demonstrate that under the correct conditions well-managed rangelands are able to support diverse assemblages of amphibians. These rangeland ecosystems may play a critical role in protecting future amphibian biodiversity by serving as an “off-reserve” system to supplement the biodiversity conserved within traditional protected areas.

AB - Pastureland currently occupies 26% of Earth's ice-free land surface. As the global human population continues to increase and developing countries consume more protein-rich diets, the amount of land devoted to livestock grazing will only continue to rise. To mitigate the loss of global biodiversity as a consequence of the ever-expanding amount of land converted from native habitat into pastureland for livestock grazing, an understanding of how livestock impact wildlife is critical. While previous reviews have examined the impact of livestock on a wide variety of taxa, there have been no reviews examining how global livestock grazing affects amphibians. We conducted both an empirical study in south-central Florida examining the impact of cattle on amphibian communities and a quantitative literature review of similar studies on five continents. Our empirical study analyzed amphibian community responses to cattle as both a binary (presence/absence) variable, and as a continuous variable based on cow pie density. Across all analyses, we were unable to find any evidence that cattle affected the amphibian community at our study site. The literature review returned 46 papers that met our criteria for inclusion. Of these studies, 15 found positive effects of livestock on amphibians, 21 found neutral/mixed effects, and 10 found negative effects. Our quantitative analysis of these data indicates that amphibian species that historically occurred in closed-canopy habitats are generally negatively affected by livestock presence. In contrast, open-canopy amphibians are likely to experience positive effects from the presence of livestock, and these positive effects are most likely to occur in locations with cooler climates and/or greater precipitation seasonality. Collectively, our empirical work and literature review demonstrate that under the correct conditions well-managed rangelands are able to support diverse assemblages of amphibians. These rangeland ecosystems may play a critical role in protecting future amphibian biodiversity by serving as an “off-reserve” system to supplement the biodiversity conserved within traditional protected areas.

KW - Anura

KW - cattle

KW - Caudata

KW - climate

KW - community

KW - conservation

KW - land-use

KW - rangeland

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85070826847&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85070826847&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/eap.1976

DO - 10.1002/eap.1976

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85070826847

JO - Ecological Appplications

JF - Ecological Appplications

SN - 1051-0761

M1 - e01976

ER -