Addressing the knowledge gap in clinical recommendations for management and complete excision of clinically atypical nevi/dysplastic nevi pigmented lesion subcommittee consensus statement

Caroline C. Kim, Susan M. Swetter, Clara Curiel-Lewandrowski, James M Grichnik, Douglas Grossman, Allan C. Halpern, John M. Kirkwood, Sancy A. Leachman, Ashfaq A. Marghoob, Michael E. Ming, Kelly C. Nelson, Emir Veledar, Suraj S. Venna, Suephy C. Chen

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

24 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

IMPORTANCE The management of clinically atypical nevi/dysplastic nevi (CAN/DN) is controversial, with few data to guide the process. Management recommendations for DN with positive histologic margins were developed by the Delphi method to achieve consensus among members of the Pigmented Lesion Subcommittee (PLS) of the Melanoma Prevention Working Group (MPWG) after reviewing the current evidence. OBJECTIVES To outline key issues related to the management of CAN/DN: (1) biopsies of CAN and how positive margins arise, (2) whether incompletely excised DN evolve into melanoma, (3) current data on the outcomes of DN with positive histologic margins, (4) consensus recommendations, and (5) a proposal for future studies, including a large-scale study to help guide the management of DN with positive margins. EVIDENCE REVIEW The literature, including recent studies examining management and outcomes of DN with positive margins between 2009 to 2014, was reviewed. FINDINGS A consensus statement by the PLS of the MPWG following review of the literature, group discussions, and a structured Delphi method consensus. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE This consensus statement reviews the complexities of management of CAN/DN. A review of the literature and 2 rounds of a structured Delphi consensus resulted in the following recommendations: (1) mildly and moderately DN with clear margins do not need to be reexcised, (2) mildly DN biopsied with positive histologic margins without clinical residual pigmentation may be safely observed rather than reexcised, and (3) observation may be a reasonable option for management of moderately DN with positive histologic margins without clinically apparent residual pigmentation; however, more data are needed to make definitive recommendations in this clinical scenario.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)212-218
Number of pages7
JournalJAMA Dermatology
Volume151
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 1 2015

Fingerprint

Dysplastic Nevus Syndrome
Nevus
Melanoma
Pigmentation
Observation
Biopsy

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Dermatology

Cite this

Addressing the knowledge gap in clinical recommendations for management and complete excision of clinically atypical nevi/dysplastic nevi pigmented lesion subcommittee consensus statement. / Kim, Caroline C.; Swetter, Susan M.; Curiel-Lewandrowski, Clara; Grichnik, James M; Grossman, Douglas; Halpern, Allan C.; Kirkwood, John M.; Leachman, Sancy A.; Marghoob, Ashfaq A.; Ming, Michael E.; Nelson, Kelly C.; Veledar, Emir; Venna, Suraj S.; Chen, Suephy C.

In: JAMA Dermatology, Vol. 151, No. 2, 01.02.2015, p. 212-218.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Kim, CC, Swetter, SM, Curiel-Lewandrowski, C, Grichnik, JM, Grossman, D, Halpern, AC, Kirkwood, JM, Leachman, SA, Marghoob, AA, Ming, ME, Nelson, KC, Veledar, E, Venna, SS & Chen, SC 2015, 'Addressing the knowledge gap in clinical recommendations for management and complete excision of clinically atypical nevi/dysplastic nevi pigmented lesion subcommittee consensus statement', JAMA Dermatology, vol. 151, no. 2, pp. 212-218. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamadermatol.2014.2694
Kim, Caroline C. ; Swetter, Susan M. ; Curiel-Lewandrowski, Clara ; Grichnik, James M ; Grossman, Douglas ; Halpern, Allan C. ; Kirkwood, John M. ; Leachman, Sancy A. ; Marghoob, Ashfaq A. ; Ming, Michael E. ; Nelson, Kelly C. ; Veledar, Emir ; Venna, Suraj S. ; Chen, Suephy C. / Addressing the knowledge gap in clinical recommendations for management and complete excision of clinically atypical nevi/dysplastic nevi pigmented lesion subcommittee consensus statement. In: JAMA Dermatology. 2015 ; Vol. 151, No. 2. pp. 212-218.
@article{b092cf4e829444f1a4b5507c9a7e4f8f,
title = "Addressing the knowledge gap in clinical recommendations for management and complete excision of clinically atypical nevi/dysplastic nevi pigmented lesion subcommittee consensus statement",
abstract = "IMPORTANCE The management of clinically atypical nevi/dysplastic nevi (CAN/DN) is controversial, with few data to guide the process. Management recommendations for DN with positive histologic margins were developed by the Delphi method to achieve consensus among members of the Pigmented Lesion Subcommittee (PLS) of the Melanoma Prevention Working Group (MPWG) after reviewing the current evidence. OBJECTIVES To outline key issues related to the management of CAN/DN: (1) biopsies of CAN and how positive margins arise, (2) whether incompletely excised DN evolve into melanoma, (3) current data on the outcomes of DN with positive histologic margins, (4) consensus recommendations, and (5) a proposal for future studies, including a large-scale study to help guide the management of DN with positive margins. EVIDENCE REVIEW The literature, including recent studies examining management and outcomes of DN with positive margins between 2009 to 2014, was reviewed. FINDINGS A consensus statement by the PLS of the MPWG following review of the literature, group discussions, and a structured Delphi method consensus. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE This consensus statement reviews the complexities of management of CAN/DN. A review of the literature and 2 rounds of a structured Delphi consensus resulted in the following recommendations: (1) mildly and moderately DN with clear margins do not need to be reexcised, (2) mildly DN biopsied with positive histologic margins without clinical residual pigmentation may be safely observed rather than reexcised, and (3) observation may be a reasonable option for management of moderately DN with positive histologic margins without clinically apparent residual pigmentation; however, more data are needed to make definitive recommendations in this clinical scenario.",
author = "Kim, {Caroline C.} and Swetter, {Susan M.} and Clara Curiel-Lewandrowski and Grichnik, {James M} and Douglas Grossman and Halpern, {Allan C.} and Kirkwood, {John M.} and Leachman, {Sancy A.} and Marghoob, {Ashfaq A.} and Ming, {Michael E.} and Nelson, {Kelly C.} and Emir Veledar and Venna, {Suraj S.} and Chen, {Suephy C.}",
year = "2015",
month = "2",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1001/jamadermatol.2014.2694",
language = "English",
volume = "151",
pages = "212--218",
journal = "JAMA Dermatology",
issn = "2168-6068",
publisher = "American Medical Association",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Addressing the knowledge gap in clinical recommendations for management and complete excision of clinically atypical nevi/dysplastic nevi pigmented lesion subcommittee consensus statement

AU - Kim, Caroline C.

AU - Swetter, Susan M.

AU - Curiel-Lewandrowski, Clara

AU - Grichnik, James M

AU - Grossman, Douglas

AU - Halpern, Allan C.

AU - Kirkwood, John M.

AU - Leachman, Sancy A.

AU - Marghoob, Ashfaq A.

AU - Ming, Michael E.

AU - Nelson, Kelly C.

AU - Veledar, Emir

AU - Venna, Suraj S.

AU - Chen, Suephy C.

PY - 2015/2/1

Y1 - 2015/2/1

N2 - IMPORTANCE The management of clinically atypical nevi/dysplastic nevi (CAN/DN) is controversial, with few data to guide the process. Management recommendations for DN with positive histologic margins were developed by the Delphi method to achieve consensus among members of the Pigmented Lesion Subcommittee (PLS) of the Melanoma Prevention Working Group (MPWG) after reviewing the current evidence. OBJECTIVES To outline key issues related to the management of CAN/DN: (1) biopsies of CAN and how positive margins arise, (2) whether incompletely excised DN evolve into melanoma, (3) current data on the outcomes of DN with positive histologic margins, (4) consensus recommendations, and (5) a proposal for future studies, including a large-scale study to help guide the management of DN with positive margins. EVIDENCE REVIEW The literature, including recent studies examining management and outcomes of DN with positive margins between 2009 to 2014, was reviewed. FINDINGS A consensus statement by the PLS of the MPWG following review of the literature, group discussions, and a structured Delphi method consensus. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE This consensus statement reviews the complexities of management of CAN/DN. A review of the literature and 2 rounds of a structured Delphi consensus resulted in the following recommendations: (1) mildly and moderately DN with clear margins do not need to be reexcised, (2) mildly DN biopsied with positive histologic margins without clinical residual pigmentation may be safely observed rather than reexcised, and (3) observation may be a reasonable option for management of moderately DN with positive histologic margins without clinically apparent residual pigmentation; however, more data are needed to make definitive recommendations in this clinical scenario.

AB - IMPORTANCE The management of clinically atypical nevi/dysplastic nevi (CAN/DN) is controversial, with few data to guide the process. Management recommendations for DN with positive histologic margins were developed by the Delphi method to achieve consensus among members of the Pigmented Lesion Subcommittee (PLS) of the Melanoma Prevention Working Group (MPWG) after reviewing the current evidence. OBJECTIVES To outline key issues related to the management of CAN/DN: (1) biopsies of CAN and how positive margins arise, (2) whether incompletely excised DN evolve into melanoma, (3) current data on the outcomes of DN with positive histologic margins, (4) consensus recommendations, and (5) a proposal for future studies, including a large-scale study to help guide the management of DN with positive margins. EVIDENCE REVIEW The literature, including recent studies examining management and outcomes of DN with positive margins between 2009 to 2014, was reviewed. FINDINGS A consensus statement by the PLS of the MPWG following review of the literature, group discussions, and a structured Delphi method consensus. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE This consensus statement reviews the complexities of management of CAN/DN. A review of the literature and 2 rounds of a structured Delphi consensus resulted in the following recommendations: (1) mildly and moderately DN with clear margins do not need to be reexcised, (2) mildly DN biopsied with positive histologic margins without clinical residual pigmentation may be safely observed rather than reexcised, and (3) observation may be a reasonable option for management of moderately DN with positive histologic margins without clinically apparent residual pigmentation; however, more data are needed to make definitive recommendations in this clinical scenario.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84922907870&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84922907870&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1001/jamadermatol.2014.2694

DO - 10.1001/jamadermatol.2014.2694

M3 - Article

C2 - 25409291

AN - SCOPUS:84922907870

VL - 151

SP - 212

EP - 218

JO - JAMA Dermatology

JF - JAMA Dermatology

SN - 2168-6068

IS - 2

ER -