A comparison of complementary and taxonomic utilization: Significance of the dependent measure

Marcia S. Scott, Daryl Greenfield, Richard C. Urbano

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

10 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Preschool children's utilization of complementary relations (e.g., environmental associates such as bird-nest, dog-bone) and taxonomic relations (e.g., items related categorically such as two or more fruit) was compared using three response measures that varied the task demands placed on the child. These three response measures were: generating a related verbal response to a single picture study card; selecting the one of two choice pictures that was related to the study pictures; justifying the picture choice selected. For one set, the correct response was related taxonomically to the study picture. For the second set, a correct response formed a complementary pair with the study picture. Based on a conceptual analysis of the task, it was argued that picture choice would be less demanding for the child than justification of the picture choice which in turn would be less demanding than generating an appropriate pair. It was predicted that as task demands increased performance would decrease for both complementary and taxonomic pairing. More importantly, functionally and perceptually available complementary pairs should be maintained at progressively higher levels relative to more abstract and hierarchically related taxonomic pairs. In addition, as task demands increase, complementary intrusions should produce one source of systematic error in the taxonomic condition. The results supported these predictions.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)241-256
Number of pages16
JournalInternational Journal of Behavioral Development
Volume8
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - 1985

Fingerprint

utilization
Preschool Children
Birds
Fruit
Research Design
Dogs
Bone and Bones
preschool child
performance

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Developmental and Educational Psychology

Cite this

A comparison of complementary and taxonomic utilization : Significance of the dependent measure. / Scott, Marcia S.; Greenfield, Daryl; Urbano, Richard C.

In: International Journal of Behavioral Development, Vol. 8, No. 3, 1985, p. 241-256.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{1afd71dd7bad415186b2f765026cc4ec,
title = "A comparison of complementary and taxonomic utilization: Significance of the dependent measure",
abstract = "Preschool children's utilization of complementary relations (e.g., environmental associates such as bird-nest, dog-bone) and taxonomic relations (e.g., items related categorically such as two or more fruit) was compared using three response measures that varied the task demands placed on the child. These three response measures were: generating a related verbal response to a single picture study card; selecting the one of two choice pictures that was related to the study pictures; justifying the picture choice selected. For one set, the correct response was related taxonomically to the study picture. For the second set, a correct response formed a complementary pair with the study picture. Based on a conceptual analysis of the task, it was argued that picture choice would be less demanding for the child than justification of the picture choice which in turn would be less demanding than generating an appropriate pair. It was predicted that as task demands increased performance would decrease for both complementary and taxonomic pairing. More importantly, functionally and perceptually available complementary pairs should be maintained at progressively higher levels relative to more abstract and hierarchically related taxonomic pairs. In addition, as task demands increase, complementary intrusions should produce one source of systematic error in the taxonomic condition. The results supported these predictions.",
author = "Scott, {Marcia S.} and Daryl Greenfield and Urbano, {Richard C.}",
year = "1985",
doi = "10.1177/016502548500800301",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "8",
pages = "241--256",
journal = "International Journal of Behavioral Development",
issn = "0165-0254",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A comparison of complementary and taxonomic utilization

T2 - Significance of the dependent measure

AU - Scott, Marcia S.

AU - Greenfield, Daryl

AU - Urbano, Richard C.

PY - 1985

Y1 - 1985

N2 - Preschool children's utilization of complementary relations (e.g., environmental associates such as bird-nest, dog-bone) and taxonomic relations (e.g., items related categorically such as two or more fruit) was compared using three response measures that varied the task demands placed on the child. These three response measures were: generating a related verbal response to a single picture study card; selecting the one of two choice pictures that was related to the study pictures; justifying the picture choice selected. For one set, the correct response was related taxonomically to the study picture. For the second set, a correct response formed a complementary pair with the study picture. Based on a conceptual analysis of the task, it was argued that picture choice would be less demanding for the child than justification of the picture choice which in turn would be less demanding than generating an appropriate pair. It was predicted that as task demands increased performance would decrease for both complementary and taxonomic pairing. More importantly, functionally and perceptually available complementary pairs should be maintained at progressively higher levels relative to more abstract and hierarchically related taxonomic pairs. In addition, as task demands increase, complementary intrusions should produce one source of systematic error in the taxonomic condition. The results supported these predictions.

AB - Preschool children's utilization of complementary relations (e.g., environmental associates such as bird-nest, dog-bone) and taxonomic relations (e.g., items related categorically such as two or more fruit) was compared using three response measures that varied the task demands placed on the child. These three response measures were: generating a related verbal response to a single picture study card; selecting the one of two choice pictures that was related to the study pictures; justifying the picture choice selected. For one set, the correct response was related taxonomically to the study picture. For the second set, a correct response formed a complementary pair with the study picture. Based on a conceptual analysis of the task, it was argued that picture choice would be less demanding for the child than justification of the picture choice which in turn would be less demanding than generating an appropriate pair. It was predicted that as task demands increased performance would decrease for both complementary and taxonomic pairing. More importantly, functionally and perceptually available complementary pairs should be maintained at progressively higher levels relative to more abstract and hierarchically related taxonomic pairs. In addition, as task demands increase, complementary intrusions should produce one source of systematic error in the taxonomic condition. The results supported these predictions.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84970296338&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84970296338&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/016502548500800301

DO - 10.1177/016502548500800301

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84970296338

VL - 8

SP - 241

EP - 256

JO - International Journal of Behavioral Development

JF - International Journal of Behavioral Development

SN - 0165-0254

IS - 3

ER -